This week’s Daryl Dixon trades moral reckoning for performative chaos. The title promises frontier justice; what we get is a flaming walker catapult and a theology that folds under pressure—a catapult of confusion masquerading as moral spectacle. The Primitives arrive with all the subtlety of a cosplay militia—torch-happy, resource-wasting, and narratively incoherent. In a world built on scarcity, launching walkers like medieval fireworks isn’t justice. It’s conceptual nonsense.
 |
| “La Justicia Fronteriza” – THE WALKING DEAD DARYL DIXON, Pictured: Óscar Jaenada as Fede . Photo Credit: Manuel Fernandez-Valdes/AMC @2025 AMC Inc. All Rights Reserved |
Season 3 wants to be a Spaghetti Western—dusty morality, lone-wolf brooding, stylized violence—but forgets that horror needs consequence. Walkers aren’t divine agents; they’re chaos incarnate. So, when Fede (Óscar Jaenada), the supposed moral anchor of Solaz del Mar, invokes “It’s God’s decision, not ours” then lets walkers rip a surviving Primitive apart instead of ordering a hanging, it’s not restraint—it’s rhetorical sleight of hand. A hanging would’ve been brutal but legible. This? It’s murder dressed up in moral genuflection.
Fede’s arc could’ve explored the tension between faith and survival. Instead, it collapses into genre drift and narrative convenience. He’s not a frontier preacher-with-a-gun—he’s a plot device in a show that’s lost its grip on consequence.
 |
| “La Justicia Fronteriza” – THE WALKING DEAD DARYL DIXON, Pictured: Hugo Arbués as Roberto. Photo Credit: Carla Oset/AMC @2025 AMC Inc. All Rights Reserved |
Echoes of Rick and Shane, Minus the Depth.
Roberto’s (Hugo Arbues) clash with Fede is a pale echo of Rick vs. Shane. Both duos represent survivalist pragmatism (Fede) versus moral idealism (Roberto), but where Rick and Shane’s conflict was layered with emotional stakes and narrative clarity, Roberto’s conflict with Fede is murky, complicated by his feud with Roberto’s father, Antonio.
The show hints that it is some kind of secret between the two men. Is it political? Personal? Ideological? The show never tells us. Instead, we get arbitrary prohibitions and hollow fallout between Justina and Roberto, who suffer for a backstory that’s never articulated.
 |
| “La Justicia Fronteriza” – THE WALKING DEAD DARYL DIXON, Pictured: Eduardo Noriega as Antonio. Photo Credit: Carla Oset/AMC @2025 AMC Inc. All Rights Reserved |
Fede’s manipulation of the sacrificial lottery to protect Justina mirrors Shane’s ruthless pragmatism, but without Shane’s psychological unraveling or narrative payoff. Justina’s (Candela Saitta) discovery of Fede’s betrayal should be a moral breaking point—but it lands flat, because the system itself is underexplored, and the emotional stakes feel rushed.
The Primitives: A Secondhand Apocalypse
The Primitives embody chaos and destruction without a philosophical core, engaging in aesthetic violence that feels more like spectacle than story. Contrast that with the Wolves from Season 6 of The Walking Dead, whose attack reshaped Alexandria’s ethical landscape and left lasting scars. Their violence had ideology. The Primitives? Just noise.
And in a universe where “burn-it-all-down” has already been masterfully deployed, trying it again without reinvention isn’t bold—it’s redundant. You never get a second chance to make a first impact. That was Season 6. This is just cosplay carnage.
Flashbacks and a California Casualty
Daryl’s flashbacks remain a mystery. They lack emotional depth and fail to connect with the present narrative, stalling momentum rather than enriching it. And Cooper (Samuel Sargent), the conveniently timed surfer-dude from California, feels like a rejected character from a YA dystopia. Dropped in as a contrived plot device, he undermines the intended levity and any potential narrative payoff.
 |
| “La Justicia Fronteriza” – THE WALKING DEAD DARYL DIXON, Pictured: Samuel Sargent as Cooper, Norman Reedus as Daryl Dixon. Photo Credit: Carla Oset/AMC @2025 AMC Inc. All Rights Reserved |
Together, these elements expose a deeper flaw in Daryl Dixon Season 3: superficial storytelling that gestures toward meaning but never earns it. It’s narrative window dressing on an empty storefront.
Legacy Lost. Stakes Flattened. Genre Drift in Full Swing.
“La Justicia Fronteriza” aims to balance legacy, spectacle, and new blood—but fumbles all three. Carol (Melissa McBride) and Daryl, once an emotional core of the franchise, are reduced to reactive shadows. Their arcs deserve mythic weight and mentorship, not repetition. Instead, the spotlight falls on Justina and Roberto. This route is fine, but narratively hollow. There’s no symbolic handoff, no emotional resonance, just recycled conflict.
Compare that to Dead City’s Maggie, whose fight for Hershel is raw and generational. Or Daryl’s earlier arc with Laurent, which didn’t offer redemption so much as reveal his inner parent—a reluctant mentor shaping a child’s future in a world that devours it.
 |
| “La Justicia Fronteriza” – THE WALKING DEAD DARYL DIXON, Pictured: Melissa McBride as Carol Peletier, Norman Reedus as Daryl Dixon. Photo Credit Carla Oset/AMC @2025 AMC Inc. All Rights Reserved |
The franchise still has life. But it needs to choose — honor its horror roots, elevate legacy characters, and invest in generational storytelling. Let the old guard become legends. Let the new generation fight for meaning.
Otherwise, The Walking Dead risks becoming a stylized echo of itself—pretty, but as hollow as the dead in Solaz del Mar
Overall Rating: 6/10
Lynette Jones
