“UnhappyEnding” is exactly the kind of episode that earns its title not because it lacks payoff, but because every resolution comes with a cost. This hour of Murder of a Killer is tense, unsettling, and deeply character-driven, peeling back layers on Angelo while quietly repositioning Maria as a woman who refuses to remain a victim. By the time the final reveal lands, the episode leaves you uneasy in the best possible way.
Angelo vs. the Myth of the Ferryman
The episode opens with a chilling reminder of just how powerful the Ferryman’s reputation is. The man Angelo interrogates would rather die than betray him, describing a monster who doesn’t just kill, but erases. This establishes the Ferryman less as a man and more as an idea, a psychological weapon that keeps everyone in line.
Angelo’s response, that men bleed, perfectly captures his fatal flaw. He believes competence and fearlessness can overcome mythology. And yet, everything that follows suggests the Ferryman is already inside Angelo’s life in ways he doesn’t yet understand.
The power station sequence is one of the episode’s strongest set pieces. The Franz Ferdinand needle drop, the efficiency of the kills, the staged crime scene, it all reinforces Angelo’s professionalism. But the discovery of the file with photos of Maria, Jeff, and his brother cracks that controlled exterior. This isn’t business. It’s personal. And for the first time, Angelo looks genuinely shaken.
 |
| "Unhappy Ending" - MEMORY OF A KILLER. Pictured: Patrick Dempsey as Angelo. Photo: Robin Cymbaly/FOX © 2026 Fox Media LLC. All Rights Reserved. |
Maria’s Refusal to Be Passive
While Angelo moves through the criminal underworld, Maria quietly reclaims her agency. Her decision to go to the gun range, to push Dave for answers, and eventually to investigate the hiking trail herself shows a woman unwilling to wait for safety to be handed to her.
The bridge scene is particularly effective. The revelation that the spot was a secret place shared with her mother adds emotional weight, tying Maria’s present fear to generational trauma. When she finds the missing boot, it’s not just evidence, it’s confirmation that her instincts are right, even when the system tells her to step back.
Her confrontation at home about moving away is one of the episode’s most honest moments. Maria’s refusal to run isn’t dramatic. She understands something Jeff and her father don’t yet. That fear doesn’t disappear just because you change locations. Her insistence on standing her ground reframes survival as an active choice, not a retreat.
Joe, Loyalty, and Inherited Damage
Joe’s arc adds surprising emotional texture. His confession about his father’s abuse and his tendency to lie when afraid reframes his earlier behaviour, not as incompetence, but as learned survival. His confession to Angelo and his promise to own his mistakes from now on, feels like a turning point. Angelo becomes a mirror for Joe: a man who owns his choices, no matter the consequences.
 |
| "Unhappy Ending" - MEMORY OF A KILLER. Pictured: Odeya Rush as Maria and Peter Gadiot as Dave. Photo: Christos Kalohoridis/ FOX © 2026 Fox Media LLC. All Rights Reserved. |
Memory, Mortality, and the Cracks in Angelo’s Armour
The episode continues to confirm Angelo's worst fear, that he may be losing time. Forgetting he built the crib hit him like a ton of bricks, leading him to try and find a solution without admitting his worst fears out loud. His call to Jane to inquire about Alzheimer’s treatments under the guise of helping his brother is pivotal. Angelo realizes that he is racing against something invisible, just as dangerous as the Ferryman.
His conversation with Nicky earlier in the episode shows that his true identity may not be as well hidden as he thinks. She clocks him immediately: the emptiness, the secrets, the sense that something doesn’t add up. Her request is simple, when this ends, end it clean. Ironically, she may already be far more entangled than either of them realizes.
The Final Twist: No One Is Untouched
The closing reveal, that the woman repeatedly calling Leo’s phone is Nicky, recontextualizes everything. Coincidence feels impossible. Whether she’s knowingly involved or catastrophically close to danger, the Ferryman’s reach suddenly feels intimate.
“UnhappyEnding” succeeds because it doesn’t offer comfort. Justice is incomplete. Truth is fragmented. Safety is an illusion. Angelo wins battles, but the war is closing in from all sides- his enemies, his past, his mind, and now his personal life.
Not every ending is meant to satisfy. Some are meant to warn you that the worst is still coming.
