Sullivan's Crossing - Out of the Blue - Review: The Weight of the Past

---

In “Out of the Blue,” the second episode of Sullivan’s Crossing Season 3, the show settles into its signature rhythm of quiet emotional revelations, interpersonal entanglements, and the healing power of community and nature, this time with a few surprises that deepen both character and theme.

The episode begins on a peaceful note, with Maggie soaking in the morning calm on her porch, her relationship with Cal finally beginning to feel stable. They make plans for a movie night, which seems like a hopeful step forward. But peace, as always in Sullivan’s Crossing, is short-lived. Sully’s resistance to Maggie’s small changes around the house is both humorous and telling. His frustration with her new coffee maker is less about caffeine and more about how uncomfortable he feels with change. It’s a subtle, ongoing conflict between a father and daughter trying to re-learn each other as adults. Scott Patterson continues to portray Sully with warmth and gruff authenticity, and here his chemistry with new character Helen offers something fresh. Their slow-blooming rapport, sparked over a leaking sink and shared interest in birdwatching, suggests the show might be setting up an unexpected and promising connection for Sully beyond his usual emotional stalemate.

“Out of the Blue" - SULLIVAN’S CROSSING. Pictured: Morgan Kohan as Maggie Sullivan and Scott Patterson as Sully. Photo: Bell Media ©2025. All Rights Reserved.

Much of the episode explores the challenges of change: welcoming it, resisting it, and learning to live with it. Maggie, for her part, is trying to reestablish her identity in a familiar but transformed place. Her impromptu visit to Cal’s cabin to ask why he never showed up after training results in disappointment, but also understanding. Cal is carrying heavy trauma, as we see in a flashback during his physically grueling Search and Rescue training. His memories of being forced to do push-ups by a paranoid and domineering father, explain his stoicism and emotional guardedness. Steve Lund’s Chief Cooper is a stark, almost militaristic presence, and his dynamic with Cal and Rafe hints at larger tensions within the local volunteer force.

There’s a beautiful juxtaposition between Cal’s struggle to stay strong and Maggie’s growing desire to settle down and find stability, even as she sacrifices her medical career to be with him. Their chemistry is gently reaffirmed, and the payoff comes late in the episode with an intimate and emotionally grounded love scene, one that’s not just physical, but built on mutual trust, vulnerability, and healing. The moment Cal asks Maggie if she’s okay, given her recent miscarriage, and she assures him she is, hits the right emotional note, tender and respectful.

Elsewhere, Edna and Frank continue to be the emotional bedrock of the show, reflecting on aging and the passage of time in a way that is honest and deeply relatable. Their conversations about lost energy, lost time, and the privilege of growing old, add emotional weight and reinforce the show's recurring themes of renewal and resilience. The use of Cree during their exchanges is a quiet but powerful affirmation of cultural identity and deep connection.

“Out of the Blue" - SULLIVAN’S CROSSING. Pictured: Tom Jackson as Frank Cranebear and Andrea Menard as Edna Cranebear. Photo: Bell Media ©2025. All Rights Reserved.

Meanwhile, Maggie’s girls’ night out with Sydney and Lola injects the episode with levity and warmth. Sydney’s tequila-fueled boldness and Lola’s shy attempt at flirting bring a welcome sense of community and fun, even if things don’t quite go as planned for Lola. The accidental wine spill on a stranger, who later turns out to be Frank’s cousin, sets up what is sure to be an awkward but endearing storyline in episodes to come. These slice-of-life moments ground the show in relatable everyday struggles, even as it deals with heavier emotional material.

The episode’s final scenes bring complications for nearly every major character. Sully, while birding with Helen, seems to be opening up again to the idea of connection and purpose, until the looming threat of a luxury resort sign signals the external pressures that may soon intrude on their quiet corner of Nova Scotia. For Cal, the news of his father’s declining health lands with emotional weight just as he’s beginning to embrace his life in Sullivan’s Crossing and his future with Maggie. The call from his mother is a reminder that no matter how far we run from the past, it eventually calls us back.

“New Beginnings" - SULLIVAN’S CROSSING. Pictured: Morgan Kohan as Maggie Sullivan and Chad Michael Murray as Cal Jones. Photo: Bell Media ©2025. All Rights Reserved.

“Out of the Blue” is an aptly titled episode, as nearly every character is blindsided by something: old memories, new relationships, inconvenient truths. But the writing keeps it all grounded, and the performances, especially from Morgan Kohan and Chad Michael Murray, carry the emotional nuance the story demands. This isn’t a show driven by sensational plot twists, but by the quiet, powerful transformations that come from facing pain, embracing change, and slowly choosing hope.

This episode is a mature, thoughtfully crafted one that continues to build emotional depth while gently expanding the series’ character arcs. It’s a reminder that healing is rarely linear, love is rarely easy, and the most meaningful moments often come quietly, sometimes even on a picnic blanket, or over a broken kitchen sink.