SpoilerTV - TV Spoilers

Stargate Universe - Franchise Fans vs. Show Fans

Stargate Universe isn't doing well in the ratings. Pleas from fans, actors, and producers alike have been sent out in hopes that there can be an upturn, else the fear is that a cancellation may be on the horizon. It seems tensions are running high, as evidenced by co-creator and executive producer Brad Wright's recent comment that puts the blame not on the product itself, but on the shoulders of former fans of the franchise.

"I don’t think if we for any reason go away, it is an issue necessarily of the quality of the product that we’ve been making. I think getting moved on the schedule has hurt us. And the fact that some of the fans that liked SG-1 and Atlantis were so angry that they have deliberately hurt us, which is unfortunate." ~ Brad Wright

This is perhaps a situation where franchise loyalty is expected to win out over show loyalty, but should that be the case? Just because you're a fan of one or two shows in a franchise does not mean that you'll necessarily be a fan of them all. It's all about individual taste rather than the name you place on the product. And if some fans have come to expect a certain level from the franchise name, yet the new entry doesn't fit with that, are they not allowed to voice their opinions?

From my own viewing habits, I was never a regular viewer of Stargate SG1. The Earth-bound nature of a space show wasn't something I rushed to see week to week. So, when a new series in the franchise was announced, it wasn't even on my radar. And I was not about to catch up on almost 10 years of show canon just to watch a spin-off. But then I caught a re-run of Stargate Atlantis and was instantly hooked. This wasn't the same Stargate as before. For one thing, they weren't Earth-bound. Plus, these characters were, quite frankly, the rejects of the SGC...and I loved them! I like seeing this type of character dynamic, mixed in with humor, in an unknown world that is far away from Earth. When Atlantis came to an end and the new Stargate Universe began, I gave it a chance. What I found was that it just didn't appeal to me. I found no commonality or likability with any of the characters and for me that's a key in my viewing. Plus, I like my sci-fi a bit lighter, while Universe was gearing towards darker themes reminiscent of Battlestar Galactica. So, the show hasn't been on my to-watch list and I've thought no more about it. Many shows have gone through the same selection process when I'm trying to determine my weekly viewing schedule. If a show catches my interest, I watch. If a show loses my interest, I don't watch. Just because it has the Stargate title doesn't mean I'm going to necessarily be a viewer.

To use another example, I'm a long-time Star Trek fan. The Original Series was way before my time, but the repeats made me fall in love with the characters when I was very young. I'd gladly spend a Saturday afternoon watching an episode or reading one of my many Star Trek novels. When The Next Generation came along, I watched it. Sure, it was different, but it was a new generation that fit with what I loved in the original series. It certainly didn't hurt that many of the original crew turned up as guest stars. Then there was Deep Space Nine. I tried it out, but it didn't hold my interest. It was a bit too stationary and a bit too dark. Did that mean DS9 was a horrible show? No, it just meant I wasn't their core audience. And it didn't mean I was giving up on the franchise either, since I enjoyed both Voyager and Enterprise. Each of these shows attracted an audience, but not necessarily the same one.

Instead of blaming fans of former shows in the franchise, perhaps Stargate producers should focus on the market they're trying to cater to. They can write the best show ever, in their opinion, but if nobody's watching it, then it's not going to make an impact. I wish the current Stargate series the best of luck with its core market. I'm just not a part of that.

You can follow Kimberly on Twitter or Livejournal. Check out her site for more articles.

Get Email Alerts

About The SpoilerTV Daily Newsreel

Every day 100's of items are submitted to us and we don't always have the time to make separate posts for the news and/or there is so much that it would quickly push all other items off the homepage.

So a result we've come up with the idea of the Newsreel, which will feature smaller shows and news items as they happen.

There will be a new Newsreel each day, and as news is added we will update the post and and push it back to the top of the site so that you can see that new items have been added. A tweet of the item will also be sent to our @SpoilerTV account.

New Items will be listed at the top of the article.

This will allow us to provide more news on more shows in a much more timely fashion
About Movie News Roundup

Rather that creating lots of new posts as new info is released and fragmenting the commentary, we thought it would be a good idea for the upcoming major movies to create a single post for each major movies that will collate all the info as it's posted.

New items will be added to the top of the list as well as the post being re-posted back to the top of the homepage when a new item is added. We will additionally send out a fresh tweet alerting you of the new information.

This will allow you to bookmark this page so that you can return to it whenever you like. It will also help consolidate all the discussion on this movie in a central place and make it less likely that you'll miss some key information.