Best Scene - The Arrow and Black Canary take down the Mayor, trading weapons as they go
Most Valuable Player - Black Canary
Biggest Shock - tie - Sara reveals herself to Oliver so quickly…and that she's trapped by him so easily
Oliver tells Diggle and Felicity that he saw Sara a year after the yacht went down
Most Emotional Scene - Quentin talks about Laurel at his AA meeting while she downs pills and wine
Biggest Aww Moment - Thea tells Roy he's a hero and they both stay with Sin until she wakes up
Most Disgusting Moment - Oliver pulls the bullet out of his side and stitches up the wound himself
Best Team Arrow Moment - Turning on the tracker
-Yes the most emotional was when Oliver told them about Sara but I actually liked all of Team Arrow in their second scene.
Best New Addition to the Show - Sorry Black Canary, this one goes to Sin
Biggest Idiot - The Mayor
-Seriously dude. First you kill your own people and then you go into a public place, a media event no less, and show your face. Put on a mask. Heck on this show, even a little eye shadow would do.
Best Introduction - Sin meets Thea - snarky fun
Weirdest Confession - Oliver asks Blood for advice about Sara and Laurel
-This could also be called the Anvil Award. Thanks for explaining the episode title, Alderman.
-I really wish she would get a bigger part. It would be interesting if she ended up being a villain because it would tie Diggle better into the story and they sorely need to do that.
Least Inspiring Leadership - tie - The Mayor kills his underling for no good reason
The Captain tells Oliver that he'll kill him or he'll kill
Best Interruption - Diggle tells Felicity to shut up about Sara
Tiny Thing Bound to Become a Huge Deal - Star Lab's particle accelerator
-I swear I've heard it mentioned in passing twice already this season. This time as a news item before the cash for guns event
Worst Foreshadowing - Oliver says Blood should be mayor and he says, "There's more than one way to save a city."
Worst Rejoinder - Diggle: "You know Oliver, someone once told me that secrets have weight. The more you keep, the harder it is to keep moving." Oliver: "You see how hard I work out." Really Oliver?
Russian prisoner: "Living - it's not for the weak."
Oliver: "Go to hell." Captain: "Can't. We're already there."
Other Great Lines -
Isabel: "Being fashionably late might do well for the club circuit but it does not inspire confidence in Wall Street."
Laurel: "Please do not ask me if I'm okay because I'm sick to death of everyone asking me that." Oliver: "I would never do that." Laurel: "Good." Oliver: "You okay?"
Sin: "I'll take a subpar breakfast over a bullet."
Oliver: "You both need to work on your definition of good news."
Captain: "Sewing is not your strong suit."
Sin: "You know you're dating a moron, right?" Thea: "It's my first and last thought of every day." Sin: "Cr**, I like her."
Screencaps by Screencapped.net