Revolution 2.07 "The Patriot Act" Review: You Can't Choose Your Family
10 Nov 2013
Reviews RevolutionThis week’s episode of Revolution, “The Patriot Act,” was written by Anne Coffell Saunders and Matt Pitts and directed by Omar Madha. Madha has a long history of sci fi and action credits including Caprica, The Secret Circle, Alphas, Grimm, and Defiance. Madha effectively uses the first scene to pick up from the last scene last week with the sound of shovelling but this week it’s from Monroe’s (David Lyons) point of view inside the coffin. Madha uses the technique of parallel shots several times in the episode to link reactions and scenes.
Flashbacks show Gene’s (Stephen Collins) growing guilt over helping the Patriots, so I believe he’s picked a side – the real good guys – but he’s too weak to go through with it. In the end, he picks his own family – and possibly the safety of the townspeople – over Aaron (Zak Orth).
I was disappointed in Rachel’s (Elizabeth Mitchell) arc this episode. She finally steps up as Charlie’s mom when she tells her that she saved Monroe because they need him, but clearly more because Charlie asked. We see her be resourceful and clever, especially in the scene with Horn (Zeljko Ivanek), but by the end, they’ve broken her again over Gene’s betrayal, and by the last scene, she’s in tears.
It was heartbreaking to go from Cynthia (Jessica Collins) assuring Aaron that anywhere they go is home as long as they’re together to being obviously terrified of what he’s become.
Loved Monroe (David Lyons) in this week’s episode. His woozy rescue of Aaron and Cynthia was still a pretty impressive fight scene, and he’s proving he can be a valuable member of the team. The scene in which he wakes up is particularly good as we see Miles (Billy Burke) with his walls at least partially down as he welcomes his still “drunk” friend back to the living. There’s a nice shot of Charlie (Tracy Spiridakos) smiling at their reunion. It’s always possible that Monroe is simply playing all of them to get to his son, but this scene when his guard is broken down by the drugs and the relief at simply being alive and getting a second chance would seem to make his conversion genuine.
Tom (Giancarlo Esposito) manages to get Jason (JD Pardo) back and come up with a new plan. It seems like he’s going to use Allenford (Nicole Ari Parker) as a stepping stone to her husband who would appear to be higher up the food chain with the Patriots as well. Esposito is his usually outstanding best as he works both sides against the middle in his scheming. I am disappointed at the turn for Parker, however. Here was an opportunity for another strong female character and she’s essentially stupidly thrown her career away by sending an ill-thought letter to high command. Further, she’s now simply reduced to trying to save her son, who she essentially abandoned – hmmmmm. Does this sound like another character to anyone else? *coughrachelcough*
Ivanek is doing an amazing job as Horn. He’s obviously got a huge chip on his shoulder – no doubt from being passed over for more brilliant scientists like Rachel and Ben and he’s obviously insane and unpredictable. There is a definite thread of insane or sanity-challenged characters on the show. Rachel and Monroe have been walking a tightrope and there’s no question that Andover was also not in his right mind. Ivanek manages to be slimey, creepy, and scary. He’s also wearing what appears to be a version of the illuminati symbol we’ve already seen. It is often re-imagined into logos. Here’s an interesting quote from an article on the symbol:
“The rays of light are said to symbolize glory. Typically, the eye will also be enclosed in a triangle. One of the most notable depictions of the Eye of Providence is the reverse side of the United States dollar bill.
Many people interpret the symbol as the eye of God as it is watching over all of mankind. Conversely, others believe it is the eye of Satan or Lucifer who they believe influences and oversees much of the happenings in the world. Either way it is always correlated with control, and the powerful few overseeing and controlling the masses.” The full article can be read here.
These comments certainly resonate with the Patriots and the use of the symbol to this point in the show. We’ve seen torture and an enforced police state – based on their blowing up a building in the town. They’ve made it pretty clear who the bad guys are here. I’m pretty excited for Tom to get to Washington so we get to see just who is running this show!
All in all a pretty satisfying episode that answered some questions, put our characters in more jeopardy and set in motion some on-going story arcs. What did you think of the episode? Is Horn creeping you out too? I’ve tried to keep this review a little shorter – does that work for you, or would you like more detail? Let me know your thoughts in the comments below!
Sign Up for the SpoilerTV Newsletter where we talk all things TV!
I think it is a great review. I would like more detail though. But, even without the detail you did a great job.
ReplyDelete"Loved Monroe (David Lyons) in this week’s episode. His woozy rescue of Aaron and Cynthia was still a pretty impressive fight scene, and he’s proving he can be a valuable member of the team. The scene in which he wakes up is particularly good as we see Miles (Billy Burke) with his walls at least partially down as he welcomes his still “drunk” friend back to the living. There’s a nice shot of Charlie (Tracy Spiridakos) smiling at their reunion. It’s always possible that Monroe is simply playing all of them to get to his son, but this scene when his guard is broken down by the drugs and the relief at simply being alive and getting a second chance would seem to make his conversion genuine."
ReplyDeleteWell put and totally agree, Lisa! This was my favorite scene in the episode and, even though some fans aren't enjoying the Neville side of things as much as last season, I really like how "drug induced" characters are being contrasted here with Jason and Monroe, especially since we know Monroe, like the Patriots (but perhaps not as well?), also used psychotropic drug programs (It might be "how" Monroe was able to convince Miles that Rachel was dead)
"It was heartbreaking to go from Cynthia (Jessica Collins) assuring Aaron that anywhere they go is home as long as they’re together to being obviously terrified of what he’s become."
It was, but I'm very anxious to see where she goes, since she's the one character who seems genuine of her faith and reconfirmed to the audience that Aaron is 'The Chosen One'! I was wondering if she was putting two and two together (Carl + Fire) and/or if her line of faith is just drawn at violence (even though Aaron saved their lives). At any rate I do like Cynthia and I hope they flesh her out a bit more, even though I can easily see using her as a device (since loosing women men love is SO thematic) to have Aaron kill an insane amount of people!!
Another great review! Thanks Lisa! :)
Thanks! I'll likely go back to a more in-depth discussion - especially with so many interesting threads starting up!
ReplyDeleteThanks for reading! This actually just occurred to me - of all the people who would be afraid of Aaron, a battered woman would be right up there. I mean when she got Carl angry he might smack her around but he wouldn't send her up in flames - which Aaron obviously could do. Her faith really does balance the scientific side of it - I hope we get more of that balance.
ReplyDeleteI'm loving the Tom side! Of course, this episode really sees him slide back into his wonderfully duplicitous side, so maybe that will make people happier?
I felt bad for cheering for Monroe last season, so I'm very relieved to be able to do it with impunity this season... ;)
Loved the review. I was pleased with this ep. Rachel being all crying and upset all the time isn't something I like, but the end of the ep with her breaking down was a very good scene especially since it had Charlie reaching out to comfort her mother. I am starting to like Allenford. Jason seems to be getting more into Monroe & Neville territory when it comes to violence. I enjoyed Gene's internal struggle between what is right and saving his family. Loved Monroe's woozy fight scene; even woozy, he still kicks a**.
ReplyDeleteTypically good review. Horn is indeed a deliciously creepy addition. I hope they don't kill him too soon!
ReplyDeleteMy hope is that with Charlie and Miles for support, she's find this moment cathartic and be able to deal with the betrayal. It is fairly easy to see Gene's side of it after all...
ReplyDeleteThanks! I'm hoping he will factor in for some time to come!
ReplyDelete"(It might be "how" Monroe was able to convince Miles that Rachel was dead)"
ReplyDeleteThere is another bit of the past I would LOVE to see explained via a flashback or two. How did Bass convince Miles that Rachel was dead? And why do it? After all, Miles had no real problem putting Rachel under arrest when she arrived. He almost hit her! It didn't seem like he had a problem, at that point, using her to get to Ben. What changed? Did he have a change of heart at some point? He must have. Did he demand that she be released? Did Bass say she had been murdered? Did he pretend she died in an accident?
Inquiring minds want to know.
I agree with both points.
ReplyDelete1) Most women who have been in abusive relationships would have a hard time dealing with the idea that their latest boyfriend - whom they considered a safe teddybear type - has killed multiple people. Let alone that he can kill people by using his mind to set them on fire! Her reaction makes perfect sense.
2) Giancarlo Esposito never disappoints me. I think his character has gone through a really natural progression this year. He's lost everything - his wife, the career he spent a decade or more building, and the power that came with it. He has only two things remaining: Jason and an overwhelming need for revenge. The duplicitous side is still there. The man used his own son to gain access to the Patriots. He let an innocent man die to gain credibility with them, too. How is that not duplicitous? Tom is still Tom.
Ya! It's def something I hope we eventually get to! Miles said he saw 'her' body, so...
ReplyDeleteI think when it gets down to it. looking back at even Emma, Bass seems like he always wants what Miles wants, so if he got wind that Miles and Rachel were attracted, I could see how he might try and keep Rachel for himself, but what really floors me, is that this is what causes Miles to attempt to assassinate, but ultimately leave, The Monroe Republic...amd not Once did Bass dangle Rachel back in front of him (like he did with Emma) to get Miles back!!
Bass may have always wanted what Miles has, but I got the impression that this desire was somewhat muted in the days before Shelley's death. Even with Emma, he had a one night stand with her that SHE initiated. A horrible thing to do to your best friend, of course, no excuses, but you'll notice that he didn't throw it in Miles' face or try to pursue a longterm relationship with her. He didn't genuinely "steal" her away. I don't think he stole Shelley from Miles. He seemed at peace in that flashback (before her death). If anyone seemed edgy in that period it was Miles. He was the one pushing a reluctant Bass to loot the nearby camp.
ReplyDeleteQUOTE: "but what really floors me, is that this is what causes Miles to attempt to assassinate Monroe, but ultimately leave The Monroe Republic
I remember the remark about Rachel's body, but I thought the final straw for Miles was when Bass has his men murder rebel families in revenge for the bombing that almost killed Miles? It was Miles' birthday, they were remembering the "good old days", then a bomb went off and Miles was almost killed. The next day he wakes up and Bass is there to check on him. Nora was there, too. Miles looks outside and sees a wagon loaded with coffins, including a child's coffin. He asks Bass what is going on and Bass says something like: "If you try to harm my family, I'll harm yours'". Miles just stared at the child's coffin, looking shaken. Didn't Bass say that Miles tried to kill him the day after that?
Either way, I would love to find out exactly what happened during the years Bass was holding Rachel hostage. Prior to Ben's death, at least, she seemed to be living in relative physical comfort.
In terms of Gene, I think he might sacrifice himself for Rachel and Charlie's sake. I think he really thought, if he complied that they would spare Rachel (which clearly they want her for something most likely technology related) and not really hurt the town...
ReplyDeleteAs for Monroe, I do agree with you that cares about Miles a great deal, but I still think that Monroe is the kind of guy that tries to have his cake and eat it too and it wouldn't surprise me if he would turn on him/them again at some point, especially since Miles has known about his son and kept it a secret all a long!!! I think between the loss of his immediate family and then the loss of Shelly and the baby, I think Monroe isn't a stable guy and depending on what his parents were actually like, I think he has spent much of his life trying to live through Miles...
Depending on who Monroe's son is (his personalty, occupation, and/or disposition, and/or Monroes need to find him) could end up driving a fork between Bass and Miles again...of course, it could also bring them together again too! XD
And Horn is making for a fun-creepy Fringe scientist! I hope too he sticks around for a bit!
I def think it's true that Miles "woke up" from what was really going on after that bombing indecent, including his own participation, but I think this reveal that he hid Emma's baby also suggest that he always knew that Bass often wasn't in a good mind set and that both characters perhaps never fully trusted each other since they both kept the lives of other people relating to each other a secret.
ReplyDeleteAnd perhaps you're right and this is what caused him to leave/assassinate Monroe. I would need to go to the wiki and/or rewatch season 1 to try and figure out when Rachel's [false] death occurred in relation to these other events, but for some reason I thought it was also around that time...
I agree it is to Bass's credit that he didn't dangle things in Miles' face, however, I also think Monroe is actually psychologically smart guy, despite his problems and usually knows what to do and what not to do. And maybe now that we have this missing Shelly and the baby piece, there is more understanding in Monroe's ability to kill families and not just men...
Good point about Miles pushing Monroe in the Monroe/Shelly flashback. I'm just saying without knowing whom she was or how they meant it's hard to judge if there is more to it than that, since with Monroe's needs to have the upper hand even on Miles has been such a strong through line...(If Emma wouldn't have regretted it, she wouldn't of ever told Miles and agree to hide the baby)
QUOTE: " tries to have his cake and eat it too and it wouldn't surprise me if he would turn on him/them again at some point... I think Monroe isn't a stable guy and depending on what his parents were actually like, I think he has spent much of his life trying to live through Miles..."
ReplyDeleteGreat assessment. They've mentioned more than once that Bass was already something of a self-destructive alcoholic and womanizer before the blackout. Which begs the question: Why?
He served two tours in Iraq. Did that experience destabilize him emotionally? Clearly, losing his parents and sisters was traumatic, and he loved them, but was his family also dysfunctional in some way? Was it a combination of all these things that caused him to be needy and destructive? Obviously, losing Shelley and the baby further destabilized Bass emotionally.
It will be interesting to see what path he takes going forward. Will he continue trying to redeem himself or will he fall back into old destructive patterns?
I don't think Bass is currently planning to double cross Miles. I think that, at least for now, Bass is sincerely determined to rebuild their friendship and find his son. Would it shock me if he betrays Miles at some later date? No. It would disappoint me, but it wouldn't shock me. He loves Miles, but their relationship is a complicated and dysfunctional one (to put it mildly). They spent most of last year trying to kill each other!
If this new character "Conor" - described as dangerous - is Bass and Emma's kid, I have a feeling trouble will ensue. Especially, if the "dangerous" new son has eyes for Charlotte. Bass may be his BFF, but I can't imagine Miles being too thrilled about having Bass' mini-me interested in his niece.
I could also easily envision Bass welcoming his son into their little makeshift family with open arms, and insisting that Miles do the same, only to have the kid double cross them ALL to avenge the death of his mother. If this kid knows how his mother died what are the odds that he wouldn't blame at least Bass (and possibly also Miles) for her death? If he doesn't hate Bass for Emma's death, he could easily despise him for the crimes he committed as President of the Monroe Republic. I enjoy the storyline, and think it could be really interesting if it's handled well, but from the characters' POV, trying to find this kid could prove to be a really stupid move.
I agree with that. I think it was a case of willful ignorance on the part of Miles. IMO he knew deep down that Bass was a broken man, incapable of leading a nation, even BEFORE the Militia was founded, but he couldn't bring himself to admit that his friend was coming unglued. He looked the other way. He allowed this man to become President of the Republic. It took him more than a decade to finally decide to kill Bass, and even then, after he made that choice, he couldn't bring himself to go through with it.
ReplyDeleteMiles, in my opinion, is almost as co-dependent as Bass. Maybe more so, because he was in his right mind, he knew things were taking a horrific turn, but he chose to stay in the Militia, taking part in their crimes, and standing by Bass. He was even willing, at least initially, to sacrifice his own flesh-and-blood (Ben and his family) to protect the Republic.
I can see where you are coming from regarding Shelley. It's certainly possible. They didn't give us any details about how they met, after all. I just hope that wasn't case, because it would be so sad if the only woman Bass ever truly loved was a just another pawn in the rivalry between Miles and Bass.
Rachel turned herself in about seven years after the blackout. Miles tried to assassinate Monroe eleven years after the blackout. Which, again, begs the question, what happened during the intervening four years?! If he thought Bass had murdered Rachel why did he stay another four years? Did Bass try to make him think that her "death" was an accident or maybe the result of a rebel attack? Is that why he stayed so long afterwards? Or did her fake death occur shortly before Miles attacked Bass? And, if that's the case, was Miles just hunky dory with the idea of her being a hostage for four years? I don't think the writers have ever mentioned when this fake death of Rachel's occurred. It would be interesting to learn a bit more of the backstory.
ReplyDeleteExcellent review Lisa! I'm still amazed how this show has found itself in it's second season! :)
ReplyDeleteThanks for taking the time to give me a time line!!
ReplyDeleteYa, those are great questions and def ones I hope we get answers to at some point, since Rachel seems to be a possible corner stone for both characters given that 4 year time period...I'm keep thinking that Rachel probably made some kind of deal like: I'll help you and Bass, but you leave my family alone...all up until the point whenever he sent Tom looking for Ben and however many years that may have taken??????
"Miles, in my opinion, is almost as co-dependent as Bass. Maybe more so, because he was in his right mind (unlike Bass), he knew things were taking a horrific turn, but he chose to stay in the Militia, taking part in their crimes, and standing by Bass. He was even willing, at least initially, to sacrifice his own flesh-and-blood (Ben and his family) to protect the Republic."
ReplyDeleteI think that was true, but I'm not sure if it's still true. I have no doubt Miles cares for Bass and maybe even understands him in a way others do not, but i think he proved by leaving the Republic, by helping Charlie, and/or being willing to face him again, that his side of the relationship isn't as bad/unhealthy as Monroe's side of it...
I can see where you are coming from regarding Shelley. It's certainly possible. They didn't give us any details about how they met, after all. I just hope that wasn't case, because it would be so sad if the only woman Bass ever truly loved was a just another pawn in the rivalry between Miles and Bass."
I only suggested otherwise because we have seen/alluded to some instances of it, but for Bass's stories sake, I agree with you! It would be better if this is one of the few times where his relationship with Shelly was of his own doing and thus why this loss is where he really looses it and morphs into the monster.
When I spoke of Miles as being possibly more dependent than Bass I was thinking of their years together before the assassination attempt, while they were still running the Militia. I agree that the dynamic has changed over the last year. He now has Charlie and Rachel back in his life and I can't imagine him ever making the same mistake he made years ago (choosing Bass and the Militia over Ben and Rachel).
ReplyDeleteI agree that Bass is emotionally broken and far less stable, in many ways, than Miles. What's more, I think Miles recognized that fact years ago. Long before the assassination attempt. Maybe even before the MIlitia was formed. Which is why I find the choices Miles made so fascinating. I know he loves Bass, but he allowed him to become leader of a nation. He actively took part in war crimes. He even abandoned his own family members. How deeply in denial must Miles have been to rationalize what Bass was doing - not to mention his own crimes - during his years with the Militia? His actions lead me to believe that Miles was also broken in some way, just not as completely as Bass.
He did eventually walk away from Bass, but even then, he shirked responsibility. He failed to kill Bass, left the other conspirators to their respective fates, and went to hideout in Chicago. It wasn't until Charlie arrived on the scene that he finally began taking some proactive steps to stop the Militia.
Sorry for rambling, I guess my point is that I don't see either of these men as heroic. There is no clear cut "good guy" in my mind. Both were responsible in different ways for the horror show that was the Monroe Republic.
You're welcome. ;-p Can you tell it's a slow day around here?
ReplyDeleteMe too! There is definitely some backstory that really needs filling in and explaining...
ReplyDeleteThanks! Yes, it's really re-invented itself in some ways. I liked it a lot last season, but I think it struggled a bit with some of the characterizations. It took Kripke a season to get his footing with Supernatural too, so I was willing to wait for the dust to settle. Now we just have to hope that more people give it a second chance...
ReplyDeleteThanks! I think Monroe is quite sincere - I was playing devil's advocate to get other's take. I completely agree that he'll do whatever it takes to win back Miles' trust. Going to protect Aaron is further proof of that, especially when he can barely stand. Sigh. Rachel. So much potential for her character and I just feel they are squandering it by flailing about with her. On the other hand, I think they have done a much better job with Charlie this season and I am liking her so much more this season. Gene really was between a rock and a hard place. I hope we don't lose Stephen Collins - he's been terrific.
ReplyDeleteNever seen Supernatural, unfortunately, but heard good things about Kripke's run. But I agree that season 1 of Revolution was good, I liked it a lot, but it always felt a little off as well. Especially in the character department, which has been fixed this season for the most part. I still hate Tom Neville, there's nothing remotely redeemable about the guy.
ReplyDeleteSeasons 1-5 of SPN are definitely worth watching. I still watch and review, but it's not what it was - but then it's hard for any show to maintain past a certain point (unless it is almost purely formula - think Law and Order or CSI).
ReplyDeleteMy saving grace for Tom is still his before the blackout persona when he was clearly a weak victim in his life. And I think that Jason may be his path back to humanity. I want to see more about how he went from the guy running with Miles to get water for Monroe's baby to the guy scheming at the beginning of last season. You have to admit Esposito is an amazing actor - I love to watch him work!
I agree. Right now I feel like we have the best of both worlds (Kripke/Bad Robot), especially since they moved away from the story of the week structure. For a dystopian-adventure show, it was really weighing it down....
ReplyDeleteBut I disagree about Tom. I think he had better material last season, but I think where they are going emotionally with him (and Jason) is much better. I agree with you that the character is the one that hasn't really had a redemption arc started, even more than Monroe, he has been painted as exceptionally self serving since even Jason's situation is of his own making, but that's not to say that Tom could still turn around and become the hero of the day! --I do hope though that me might get something heart warming out of him eventually...Either that, he could turn out to be the biggest villain in series.XD
Well, to be honest, I think they should just write Tom off somewhere this season. His arrogance and petulant anger annoy me to no end, he betrays everyone for his own gain. Jason, as a person and a character, would be much better off without the negative anchor that is Tom.
ReplyDeleteI'm sorry, but I really loathe Tom Neville. :P
Esposito is an amazing actor, for sure, I have rarely loathed a character as much as I loathe Tom Neville. As much as I would love to see how he became the man he is today, from being a pushover to being the one that pushes people over, I feel the show would be better off without Tom Neville. And so would Jason I think.
ReplyDeleteHey, you can't help what you feel, but the truth is Tom's past has hardly been touched on. We kind of get the sense that he shares a bend with Pittman, being Bullied (at least for him as an adult), let alone the Race issue in relation to American History, but I think without knowing where exactly Tom is coming, it's def hard to have much empathy for the guy. He's come off as extremely ruthless and takes HUGE risks!! JE just does SUCH a good job at it that I still find him interesting to watch...
ReplyDeleteI do agree that Esposito is a blast to watch. :)
ReplyDeleteOkay, you and Lisa are convincing me to give Neville another chance with your excellent points. This is not good, okay, a little good. lol.
But, imo, such a change cannot be too far off from where we are now.
I think the fact that you loathe him means Esposito is doing his job! ;)
ReplyDelete