Mastodon Mastodon Mastodon Mastodon Mastodon Revolution - 1x17 "The Longest Day" - Overview & Speculation


    Enable Dark Mode!

  • What's HOT
  • Premiere Calendar
  • Ratings News
  • Movies
  • YouTube Channel
  • Submit Scoop
  • Contact Us
  • Search
  • Privacy Policy
Support SpoilerTV
SpoilerTV.com is now available ad-free to for all premium subscribers. Thank you for considering becoming a SpoilerTV premium member!

SpoilerTV - TV Spoilers

Revolution - 1x17 "The Longest Day" - Overview & Speculation

15 May 2013

Share on Reddit

Hello Revolutionaries! Straight off the bat I have to say that this week's episode is the kind of Revolution I like to see!

This week's episode starts out right off the heels of the last episode. Nora continues to be temperamental, as she suddenly rejects Miles again expressing fear of loss as her primary reason, while Tom Neville continues to brown beat and get into the face of his son, basically threatening Jason that he is not going away any time soon!

But all of that, as always, is short lived, as Charlie had watched Jason emotionally deal with his father from afar and goes to comfort him, but in a short instant Charlie hears noise and discovers Monroe has launched an air strike! She runs to the top of a brick building to ring the warning Bell.

The following scenes show the other characters in the midst of chaos. Rumble and debree is everywhere when Miles comes to. After screaming for Charlie he finds Nora and together they find Tom with a wounded Jason. After a few minutes of questioning, Jason admits he left Charlie behind in the rubble, not knowing if she was alive or not. Miles a bit upset yells at him about this, but Jason who clearly is in a lot of pain and possibly feels guilty for his actions begs to take his own life and asks for a gun. Tom denies Jason the opportunity and offers to get Jason out of the war zone. Miles wishes Tom luck and he and Nora continue to look for Charlie.

In the mean time back in Philadelphia, Jeremy talks Monroe to step outside his office for once to get a drink. Monroe agrees, but the minute they're outside they have their own air strike and attack to worry about, as Jeremy and Monroe barley escape back to Monroe's office alive. 

Back at his office again, a cool as cucumber Monroe pours Jeremy and himself a drink there, as Jeremy starts to muse over their near death experience, but again, as Monroe always does, he turns the events on Jeremy, siting that all must be conspiracy, --that Jeremy intentionally wanted him killed! -Jeremy tries to laugh at the idea suggesting it was most likely Georgia, but Monroe's men turn towards Jeremy in an attack formation. Jeremy, truly fearless, tells Monroe a long over due truth, that Monroe may conquer the continent, but in the end his paranoia will leave him all alone and he wouldn't wish that on his greatest enemy. Monroe suddenly, going from over emotional to apathetic, steps out of his office and shuts the door. We hear a single shot ring out.

Elsewhere in The Plains Nation Aaron and Rachel are able to find an old computer store or computer repair store, as Aaron looking over notations strips apart various computer components, while Rachel sits in pain with her leg on the floor. Quickly we learn that Aaron is constructing a device that will activate the flashing pill-shape device Rachel took from Danny's body. She explains that this is first generation nano-tech and it helped keep Danny alive by literally healing his lung tissue, but she warns sometimes the process of using it can have adverse affects.

Aaron is able to activate the nano tech and he proceeds to put it in her wounded area. At first the pain of the technology seems unimaginable. The audience isn't so sure if it's going to work or make everything worse, but after a bunch of horrific screaming, it begins to heal, until the wound becomes nonexistent! Unfortunitely for them a man was watching. He aims his riffle at them and demands to know how they did that!

The next thing we know he has sort of taken them captive and brought them to his house. There his wife asking if they are healers, shows them their son lying injured on the couch. Rachel talk the boy, as he explains he took a tumble of a horse, as he was trying to impress a girl, but resulted in breaking his ribs. Rachel says they need to go back to the shop and they would be glad to help. 

At the shop Aaron thinks that they are going to help the boy by removing the nano tech from Rachel's leg and reactivate for the boy, but Rachel says she will do no such thing and just getting their things so they can move onto the Tower. Aaron completely disappointed in her behavior makes the best point of all. What's the point of having technology, if we don't use it to save people's lives?! -Rachel explains that's not why she want's to turn the power back on, but so she can have her revenge against Monroe!

At Philadelphia, back in his office, Monroe learns the the attack was on behalf of the Georgia Federation. It appears he killed Jeremy unnecessarily...

 Back with Miles and Nora still in the middle of an attack Nora expresses her concern that Charlie might be dead, and like she expressed in the opening scene, that she doesn't want to loose him too. But Miles tells her that he's not going to do to Charlie what he did to her mother. "Her mother?", Nora considers, as this sparks a gutsy move to run out into the open and lead the Monroe ground soldiers away from the location they hadn't been able to search. 

Tom had been protecting Jason, but also gets shot in shoulder, but tells Jason not to worry. He's going to get Jason out. Charlie had finally found away out of the rumple that she had been caught under. She sees Nora run and is able to run the opposite direction to find Miles. The two embrace.

Sometime later in yet another hospital like place, Jason wakes up with Charlie at his side. Jason tells Charlie he's sorry for leaving her behind. Forgivingly Charlie tells him it was not his fault and two experience their first kiss, as Tom watches from outside the room, with a look that is hard to read.

The final scene however, we learn that Nora was captured by the Monroe Republic and is brought to a room where there Monroe himself waits for her. "Nice to see you again, Nora.", he says as they drag Nora in!!!!!


For me this was one of the best episodes since episode 1x13. We finally move away from the story of the week to gear up to the here and now in terms of moving forward for the end of season 1's story. I felt that the episode was well executed and that each actor had scenes written that gave them moments to shine!

To start I will get into this story with Tom. It was nice to see him remove a few good shades of darkness for the sake of his son and to see a less demonstrative side willing to take a bullet for him, but this leads me to the actions of Jason, which although I think are understandable, I can't help to think his plea to die goes deeper than his injuries and maybe even leaving Charlie behind. It's true on so many occasions that Jason has protected Charlie and I was glad she didn't stick it to him like she had before, but given the way Jason has been introduced in the serious (a spy and a traitor) and as a viewer trusting most of Charlie's instincts (such as her rejections of Jason), I can't help to think he's responsible for this attack or something else coming.

Rachel's story is also highlighted. It becomes clearer to the audience, like so many of the older characters, that they all struggle for control. It's easy to understand why Rachel feels the way she does, but the truth is her whole experience as an adult has done nothing but harden her, as she seeks revenge, but I was glad that at least Charlie's good intentions rubbed off, as he continues to step up and remind Rachel, while also telling the audience, that Rachel's goals are ultimately selfish and won't solve anything, as she became the thing she claims to hate! We also learn more exclusively that Rachel and Miles had a past, a fling, and that Rachel seems to imply that it was a bad fling at that, but like Miles, I could easily see her playing down their true emotions and feelings for the sake of survival and for the pain that they seem to cause each other.

And briefly taking a segway, the nano-tech was pretty cool! I had speculated that it could physically change matter acting as a type of God Particle. In this case we see it physically heal a wound!! -But I have to wonder if it can also "heal" people emotionally and/or make people feel intensely more broken, as the Monroe Republic in general and people in that area post blackout always struck me as more monstrous than other people we have seen? It's also again an interesting contrast, thinking back to Maggie, the kind doctor who bled to death, while the currently malicious Rachel can heel her leg and be on her way! 

This leads me then to Nora. As I have mentioned in other overviews, I feel strongly that her story is gearing up to some ill-fated end. Her character in the last few episodes has gone from somber and in the background to character who's temperament seems flippant and/or suddenly unstable, as she climbs back into the forefront. Much like that alligator metaphor ("Kashmir"), we don't really understand why she is behaving this way, but perhaps even more than Jason, should we also be worried about her conduct and loyalties?? At the end if the episode she is taken to Monroe, who acknowledges a previous relationship or connection. We never really knew when Miles and Nora met, only that at some point prior to the series she had joined the rebels and had been captured to do slave work, dragging the helicopter across the forest (which by the way is curious considering Monroe had no power). I don't believe we were ever told if she was with Miles and/or apart of the Monroe Republic during the time Miles was, but it's evident now that Nora might be left in a compromising position, let alone if she had already made some kind of deal with Monroe...

And lastly, I was sad to see Jeremy go, as Mark Pellegrino is welcome addition to any cast. I had hoped because they chose to film the scene without the audience actually seeing it, that somehow Jeremy survived, playing to the idea that no one really knows what happens behind close doors (and somebody as paranoid as Monroe should have been there to watch), but I doubt I'm that lucky! All of these throw away Monroe militia characters are pointing out the dismantle of the Monroe Republic one way or another. And I even though I don't expect Monroe to die, I could see his militia falling apart, but I would surely love the twist if Jeremy and other Militia members have turned on Monroe and took this missed-opportunity to kill him to try and at least disarm his paranoia!

So what did you guys think? Any conspiracy theories out there about Jeremy, The Georgia Federation, Jason, Tom, Nora, or the Tower?!! Sound off in the comments below!

References:
The Longest Day is a 1959 novel by Cornelius Ryan telling the story of D-Day during WWII and the Invasion of Normandy. The novel is based on interviews from various British, Canadian, French, and German officers and civilians, but is written in more novel-like style making it more about the lives of people, than a bland series of interviews.

The novel was adapted into film in 1969 staring John Wayne and includes iconic co-stars Henry Fonda & Sean Connery. The movie was also filmed in black and white, is filmed in a style of "docudrama", and is one of the most expensive black and white films made until 1993, as military consultants and many French film locations were used in trying to make the historic events more authentic.

In terms of Revolution there's the obvious connection to violent acts of war, but at this point D-Day being such an incredible invasion and freeing France of German occupation, I can only assume it's foreshadowing the events of the finale in relation to the tower and the Monroe Republic.

Bad Robot Factor:
Many of the scenes through out the episode relating to air strike attacks, especially the scenes involving Miles & gang, are VERY reminiscent to the opening post crash scenes during "The Pilot" of LOST. In similar fashion people are disorientated and put into precarious life threatening situations.












Note: Much like the black and white film, The Longest Day, LOST's budget for their TV Pilot which no doubt was due to those opening crash scenes, was the most expensive Pilot for TV ever made prior to 2004. Both also related to the ocean and beach scenes.

There are really no other direct parallels to Bad Robot works, but Rachel's pursuit of revenge over love/compassion is again similar to the actions and ultimate beliefs of Irina Derevko on Alias.

"Only the paranoid survive." is a pretty memorable line from Person of Interest's Harold Finch, as season 2 highlighted what precautions Finch was willing to take to protect the machine and just how much that dedication could alienate him from making real connections. Monroe continues to be a source of similar speculation, but to much a darker point. Other characters on Revolution also show falls to darkness from deep betrayals and enabling their ability to trust.

This paranoia of Monroe's could also then be supporter of The Every Man For Himself philosophy, which we see that Monroe isn't or hasn't been a the only characters out for themselves, as Rachel was also featured with similar ideas, as Aaron was trying to set straight in this episode. In LOST a similar debate is set up, as the following speech from character Jack Shephard is one of the strongest, if not the strongest philosophical ideal presented:

"Leave him alone! It's been 6 days and we're all still waiting. Waiting for someone to come. But what if they don'y? We have to stop waiting. We need to start figuring things out. A women died this just going for a swim and he tried to save her, and you're about to crucify him? We can't do this. Every man for himself is not going to work, It's time to start organizing  We need to figure out how we're going to survive here. Now, I found water, up in the valley. I'll take a group in at first light. If you don't want to go, then find another way to contribute. Last week most of us were strangers. But we're all here now. And God knows for how long we're going to be here. Bit if we can't live together, we're going to die alone."


And the only time we have seen nano-tech was on Fringe during it's fourth season, as William Bell was using it to trigger Olivia to be his all encompassing energy absorbing device, paving way to make his brave new world!


























9 comments:

  1. Thanks for the review!!!

    There're two parts that I don't understand in this episode:

    1, As you said about Nora. Her attitude towards the relationship with Miles.If she thought it's a bad decision, why she wanna do it in the first place? I mean, she tried to get Miles's attention in previous eps for a long time, in last episode she finally did it, but after that she regret it? Besides, she ran away from Miles and was caught by Monroe. She was the one wanna join in the rescue-Charlie-action VOLUNTARY, when she realized there're around by enemies then she gave it up? It just wasn't kinda thing that Nora did. I think the writer just tried to find an excuse to get Nora caught, but this wasn't the best way.

    In 1x09 we've known Nora was with Miles when he's General(this's confused because at that time Miles should also take care of Rachel, at least Nora should know about her since she and Miles were together back then), so my guess is maybe Nora was a former Militia and betrayed Monroe as Miles did?

    2, About Aaron's attitude in the final part. He wanted to save that child by nanotech, but did he recognize that he had to TAKE IT OUT of Rachel's knee then programmed it??? They didn't have doctor for the operation, didn't have equipment, and Rachel's wound looked so bad before she's healed, did he ever think about her a little bit? If I have to make a choice between a friend and a stranger, i'll def choose my friend without hesitations.

    The flashbacks are my favorite:) Elizabeth and Billy performed so great that I could feel the intense from their eye contacts and their expressions even without a word! But what changed Miles from a guy claimed that he didn't care about her and family, to a guy regret that he would never have left if she's alive? So curious about it!!! hopefully we could see more of flashbacks!!!!

    I also like the family bonding in this episode, between Miles and Charlie, Tom and Jason. The hug between Miles and Charlie was so sweet;) From what Rachel said about the fling, it's getting more clear that Miles is Charlie's father:) waiting for the truth.

    ReplyDelete
  2. 1. Ya. I think there has to be some reason she would suddenly begin to act this way. I know she said she fears loosing him, but I still think that fear has to be brought on by something...

    2. Good point. Although I agree it would be a massive pain to retrieve and reactivate the device, I can understand Aaron's concern for the boy. The truth is that we don't know if the "effect" of Rachel's agenda is going to be good for the majority of humanity, or if it's going to cause more devastation (especially to people @ The Plains Nation)? -But it would have surely been more sadistical if Rachel would have healed him, only to potentially turn around and kill him! -Also though supporting the idea that it really might not have been necessary, Ribs usually heal themselves. It's only fatal when they puncture an organ and we didn't get any wind if that was the case, but I do think part of the scene, the reveal that the boy did it for a girl, went hand in hand with her disgust she has for Miles in the flashback and Monroe in the current playing at her "blind rage", as Aaron is more of a voice of reason than she is.

    I also agree that sometimes out plots are a little too conviniant and straight forward to the point where it gets hard to believe, which is probably why I question it so much! :D

    ReplyDelete
  3. Forgot to mention, that in the flashback, we know Miles and Rachel had a thing when they're young. But how about Emma? Miles, Monroe and Emma grew up together as they said in previous ep, So does it mean they all knew each other since childhood(Rachel knew about Emma as well)? How is it possible that Miles, Monroe and Emma had a love triangle meanwhile Miles was with Rachel? It didn't make any sense:(((

    I really need a timeline for this whole thing...

    I'm looking forwards to the rest of episodes, hopefully we could get at least some answers:) just like Lost, an answer revealed always followed by many new questions:)

    ReplyDelete
  4. Ya. Without giving us dates, it's hard to figure out when everything happened. I can't figure out either if Rachel was with Miles before she married Ben, or after she married Ben, or when she married Ben?? It's all a bit hazy at the moment. It will be nice when we get some clarity, but I would assume it must be "after" Emma, since it seems likely Charlie is his daughter, unless of course this "fling" happened before that and then they rekindled it again later??? Super confusing XD

    ReplyDelete
  5. This is the sort of episode that makes believe that stupid writers in Hollywood should be dealt with like the Chinese Engineers that fail to make a decent home appliances.

    Was it a shining moment when Miles says "Mole Found His Base"? A Base with a big Flag Flying over head. The Base that is sitting out in the middle with no protection... The same man that knows Monroe has Choppers and Power! So, basically Monroe would never think to use those Choppers or other Aircraft for Recon? Monroe would never use ground based scouts either apparently in Miles' belief-- because only a Mole could tell Monroe where Miles is! I mean that is absurd.

    You clearly don't understand what the Higgs Boson Particle (or Particles) does(do). The nanobots would merely constructed tissue at either an atomic level or molecular level. Meaning in short it would either put together long chains of carbon atoms to form the necessary human tissue. It would be like assembling DNA, RNA in the Mitochondria... It is nothing like what the Higgs Boson does for giving matter mass. It wouldn't change the matter at all. It would merely take resources in the human body already present for healing and rapidly construction the needed tissue or bone.

    Maybe Kripke just likes the Longest Day??? The best movie about rebellion however is The Battle Of Algiers by Gillo Pontecorvo-- it is so good in 2003 the Pentagon showed it before they invaded Iraq as an object lesson to American Generals.



    The rest of your review is just full of gushing... I think you need to be more objective.

    ReplyDelete
  6. If you had been following my reviews, you would know that I never said that Nano tech was "the God Particle" (Higgs Bosen), but rather a type of tech that allows one to really "Play God" (a pun on 'God particle', or another kind of God Particle), as Revolution has higher spiritual themes!! "Finally" we see the tech physically "heal" something....

    I do think at times there are things like finding the base camp that seem silly, as you say, it's exposed. But I also said this was my favorite episode since 1x13, as the others were way more run of the mill and more procedural, as the story of week was highlighted and somewhat slowing us down, thus to say that I'm not objective (or in your mind don't criticize enough), is also unfair and perhaps not very objective on your part, --maybe you should stop being over judgmental, or stop "bashing".



    Obviously Kripke likes The Longest Day (it's an interesting movie!), but episode titles and/or references are picked in order to bring the pop culture together and because D-Day is so important an iconic, it makes sense that the deal with the Tower is meant to invoke that kind of historic significance in this reality.


    Revolution is actually is low on my list of favorite Bad Robot works, because of some of these things, but that doesn't mean I don't like it, or that I can get beyond some plot holes for the sake of bigger story and characters whom I much enjoy. I find it's always better to take the good with the bad and have some patients.

    ReplyDelete
  7. I loved all the flashbacks regarding the history between Miles and Rachel. Frankly, I'm of the opinion that you can't trust a WORD that comes out of Rachel's mouth, so I'm not convinced she thought her youthful fling with Miles as something she's regretted every day since. Miles certainly seemed to believe there was something more between them. I guess the questions comes down to when Rachel was playing Miles, was it when they wer together or when she turned herself in years later?

    I'm not convinced that I'd call Nora running out as a distraction so Miles could get to Charlie a 'gutsy' move. Honestly, I thought it looked a bit more suicidal than gutsy. There have been obvious hints about a tension between Miles and Rachel, some of which Nora was there to witness. So when Miles says he can't leave Charlie for dead, like he did Rachel, I think something clicked in Nora's mind. I think she put it together that if Miles hadn't believed Rachel was dead, there would never have been a Miles/Nora relationship at all.

    I think it was in Kashmir that Charlie asked Nora about Miles' friendship with Monroe. She asks Nora if she was with Miles when he was General and she says yes. So we can speculate further on the timeline that Miles' relationship with Nora started after he thought Rachel was already dead, but before Miles' assassination attempt on Monroe.

    ReplyDelete
  8. I called it gutsy because she clearly could die. I agree it's also suicidal, but it still relies on a gut instinct or a gut impulse to take that kind of chance.


    But I also think she was acting weird before she made that decision. That there's something about their relationship status that is suddenly bothering her. She's torn about whom Miles is and what she wants from him. She's scared, but why now all the sudden is this coming out? What did we as viewers miss that brought her this state? Was it Emma, or is it that she's mad at herself because she doesn't know if she can trust her own feelings? Is this going back to her sister, her mother, her father???


    Even though I think your right that his explanation about Charlie in relation to Rachel is what triggered Nora's actions in that moment, it's still going hand in hand with other moments she has been having. So it seems like it might go deeper than Rachel and that Rachel is just a catalyst for whatever it is Nora can't shake.



    And ya, I think you're right that was addressed in "Kashmir"!! And That's what I had been thinking, but I honestly I wasn't sure. So thanks for refreshing my memory.

    ReplyDelete
  9. Thanks for the review!!!

    There're two parts that I don't understand in this episode:

    1, As you said about Nora. Her attitude towards the relationship with Miles.If she thought it's a bad decision, why she wanna do it in the first place? I mean, she tried to get Miles's attention in previous eps for a long time, in last episode she finally did it, but after that she regret it? Besides, she ran away from Miles and was caught by Monroe. She was the one wanna join in the rescue-Charlie-action VOLUNTARY, when she realized there're around by enemies then she gave it up? It just wasn't kinda thing that Nora did. I think the writer just tried to find an excuse to get Nora caught, but this wasn't the best way.

    In 1x09 we've known Nora was with Miles when he's General(this's confused because at that time Miles should also take care of Rachel, at least Nora should know about her since she and Miles were together back then), so my guess is maybe Nora was a former Militia and betrayed Monroe as Miles did?

    2, About Aaron's attitude in the final part. He wanted to save that child by nanotech, but did he recognize that he had to TAKE IT OUT of Rachel's knee then programmed it??? They didn't have doctor for the operation, didn't have equipment, and Rachel's wound looked so bad before she's healed, did he ever think about her a little bit? If I have to make a choice between a friend and a stranger, i'll def choose my friend without hesitations.

    The flashbacks are my favorite:) Elizabeth and Billy performed so great that I could feel the intense from their eye contacts and their expressions even without a word! But what changed Miles from a guy claimed that he didn't care about her and family, to a guy regret that he would never have left if she's alive? So curious about it!!! hopefully we could see more of flashbacks!!!!

    I also like the family bonding in this episode, between Miles and Charlie, Tom and Jason. The hug between Miles and Charlie was so sweet;) From what Rachel said about the fling, it's getting more clear that Miles is Charlie's father:) waiting for the truth.

    ReplyDelete

NOTE: Name-calling, personal attacks, spamming, excessive self-promotion, condescending pomposity, general assiness, racism, sexism, any-other-ism, homophobia, acrophobia, and destructive (versus constructive) criticism will get you BANNED from the party.