Spoiler TV: The Best TV Show Competition 2011 - R2 - Day 17 - Castle vs. Chuck & Flashforward vs. The X-Files
29 Jun 2011
Cancelled Shows Castle SpoilerTV Article TV Show CompHey Guys,
Welcome to the second round of the competition! 64 shows have become 32, the competition beginning to get serious already, some big shows already gone and some more certain to depart before the final 16 places are decided.
In the final day of round one there were victories for Nikita, How I Met Your Mother, Firefly and Battlestar Galactica, all of which had relatively comfortable passages into the second stage. The Firefly-Battlestar clash will surely create sparks as the second round draws to a close.
Today at the start of the second round we have a mega-match-up a Castle takes on Chuck as well as an intriguing battle between Flashforward and The X-Files... The results of todays polls are sure to be interesting and a good indicator of whether any of these shows have a chance to reach the final few rounds!
The rules for, for anyone new to the competition are very simple. There will be new sets of shows against each other every day in a new set of polls... simply vote for your favourite and the show with the most votes will win that days poll and head into the next round.
Don't forget to spread the word, and tweet out the competition to friends as well as facebook liking the post...
Also if you are taking part in the prediction competition, don't forget to follow your scores HERE We already have no perfect brackets left in the competition, Round 1 so far has been ruthless! Sergey Sevostianov has maintained his lead of two points, standing tall at the top with 30 points.
All that's left to say, is good luck to every show...
... and let the battles begin!
Round 2
Castle vs. Chuck
Castle
Seasons: 3 (2009- )
Major Awards: 4 Emmy Nominations
2010 Competition Placing: N/A
Chuck
Seasons: 4 (2007- )
Major Awards: 2 Emmy Wins, 2 Emmy Nominations
2010 Competition Placing: 17th
Flashforward vs. The X-Files
Flashforward
Seasons: 1 (2009-2010)
Major Awards: 1 Emmy Win, 2 Emmy Nominations
2010 Competition Placing: 20th
The X-Files
Seasons: 9 (1993-2002)
Major Awards: 16 Emmy Wins, 46 Emmy Nominations & 5 Golden Globe Wins, 7 Golden Globe Nominations
2010 Competition Placing: 5th
Most Voted-In Polls:
1. Breaking Bad vs. The Vampire Diaries - 2046 votes
2. Dexter vs. Supernatural - 1922 votes
3. Criminal Minds vs. Burn Notice - 1744 votes
Previous Rounds:
Day 1 - Castle vs. The Walking Dead & Desperate Housewives vs. Chuck
Day 2 - Flashforward vs. Scrubs & Alias vs. The X-Files
Day 3 - Criminal Minds vs. Burn Notice & Dexter vs. Supernatural
Day 4 - MASH vs. The Sopranos & Farscape vs. Charmed
Day 5 - House vs. True Blood & NCIS vs. The Big Bang Theory
Day 6 - Dollhouse vs. Pushing Daisies & Arrested Development vs. 24
Day 7 - Community vs. White Collar & Breaking Bad vs. The Vampire Diaries
Day 8 - Sex & The City vs. The Wire & The OC vs. LOST
Day 9 - Fringe vs. Modern Family & Glee vs. Greys Anatomy
Day 10/11 - Prison Break vs. Veronica Mars, Gilmore Girls vs. ER, The Good Wife vs. Smallville & Gossip Girl vs. Game of Thrones
Day 12 - Heroes vs. Six Feet Under & The West Wing vs. Buffy
Day 13/14 - Bones vs. Mad Men, The Mentalist vs. Doctor Who, Oz vs. Stargate SG1 & Angel vs. Friends
Day 15/16 - Nikita vs. 30 Rock, Parks & Recreation vs. HIMYM, Firefly vs. JAG & Cold Case vs. Battlestar Galactica
As always, enjoy the competition and don't forget to comment on who you voted for below so we can all agree/disagree with you!
Any queries email me at adamdharris@spoilertv.com
Also, you can keep up to date easily with the competition by following me on Twitter @AdDHarris
Good Luck!
Adam
Sign Up for the SpoilerTV Newsletter where we talk all things TV!






I voted for Chuck, which is great fun and for The X-Files, which is a million times better than Flashforward on every level :)
ReplyDeleteCastle and the X-Files. If Chuck was still in its earlier seasons it would have been a harder choice.
ReplyDeleteSame here
ReplyDeleteCastle and X-Files!!!! :)
ReplyDeleteCastle and of course X-Files.
ReplyDeleteChuck and The X-Files.
ReplyDeleteI haven't seen Castle, and I was a big fan of Chuck once, seasons 1 and 2 were amazing and even if seasons 3 and 4 weren't nearly as good, I still like the show, so my vote went for Chuck.
I haven't seen The X-Files yet, but even I know it would be a travesty if The X-Files loses against FlashForward (FF shouldn't even be in the competition as far as I'm concerned). In round 1 there may have been some shows that would have gone much further in the competition if only they were more popular, but having Mulder & Scully losing against Joseph Fiennes' frozen eyebrows would definitely be the biggest shock of all.
only x-files
ReplyDeleteCastle and X-Files for me today.
ReplyDeleteI prefer Chuck by far, but realise the Castle fandom is large and vocal.
Voted Chuck and X-Files, but I fully expect Castle to win (I chose Castle in the bracket). I was completely surprised to see Flashforward bear Scrubs, as I had Scrubs winning this round so... My bad lol.
ReplyDeleteChuck FTW for me. And I had to vote for FlashForward, even though X-Files is the better show. Just gives me another opportunity to say BECAUSE I WAS LOADED, OK?!?!?!?!? :-D
ReplyDeleteI'm glad Castle's got a strong lead at the moment. Keep it up!
ReplyDeleteand X-Files. As much as I loved Flashforward for the year it was on.
I voted for Castle and Flashforward
ReplyDeleteMe too :)
ReplyDeleteI had to choose Chuck, but I love both shows. It was a hard choice, and then, X-Files.
ReplyDeleteDarn you, Spoiler TV for making me make such hard choices!
Castle and the X-Files.
ReplyDeleteI've seen 2 seasons and 1 episode of Castle and while it was enjoyable I don't quite get why it's so popular. I voted for Chuck, which I've seen all four seasons of.
ReplyDeleteIn the below poll I've only seen Flashforward but I do believe X-Files is infinitely better.
Castle and The X Files
ReplyDelete(How is Flashforward still in the competition??)
It's ridiculous that FF is even getting votes against the X-Files...
ReplyDeleteCastle & The X-Files.
ReplyDeleteXF has been my very fave show since 1994. Castle as my fave for currently running shows. I wonder if it has something to do with, that Rob Bowman has a hand in both?
I just HAD to vote for flashforward. I loved the show and I'm still sad it got cancelled. That reminds me ... I meant to get the DVDs from the DVD rental store and watch the whole season again.
ReplyDeleteCastle vs. Chuck? I watch / know neither, so no vote from me for that poll ...
I voted for Castle in the first poll,as while I love both shows,Castle is my favorite show on air at this time.
ReplyDeleteIn the second poll I voted the X-Files...obvious reasons...
why? =) People can vote for whatever they want. I for one really liked FF, but never really watched X-Files 'cause I didn't like the few episodes I saw and never really got into it ... =)
ReplyDeleteBesides ... FF is gonna lose (by far) anyways, so grant them those few votes at least ;)
Castle is the best show on TV at this moment can you just look at the finale of season 3 only and you can see the drama! XFiles was my favorite for the time period there were so many Mulderisms!
ReplyDeleteIt beat Scrubs :(! I mean, I thought it was a decent show... But Scrubs!
ReplyDeleteI've seen a few episodes of Castle and the first 2 seasons of Chuck. They are both decent but not appointment TV for me. I'm going with Chuck because it started off with a good premise and I remember it better.
ReplyDeleteThe second is absolutely no contest. The X-Files all the way!
Ha! I think you are safe on that one. If the X-Files gets even close to losing this one, I will be the one calling conspiracy this time. The X-Files has a lot of friends on this site because most of the shows people like here owe something to its success.
ReplyDeleteI think things are a bit skewed this year because instead of voting the way they actually feel people are voting with their bracket. I understand voting with your bracket when you don't know either show but I don't remember people letting their bracket sway their vote about shows they do have an opinion on last year. It's different and possibly a self-fulfilling prophecy if everyone just votes their bracket.
ReplyDeleteI have only voted with the bracket the 1 time it aligned with my voting... :)
ReplyDeleteI know! Poor Scrubs :(
ReplyDeleteAlthough I think a lot of people did create their brackets using their own preferences as to which shows they enjoy, so in that respect it's not quite as skewed.
ReplyDeleteI know you always vote with your heart, but man, you and your bracket have only agreed once? That's tough! Tell me that once was Veronica Mars or Supernatural. My head and heart have at least agreed 5 times so far. :-) Apparently I don't watch popular TV.
ReplyDeleteCastle's the better show from a quality standpoint (and I still enjoy watching it), but Chuck's high points and over-the-top characters have been way more entertaining to me overall so I voted for it. I haven't seen X-Files, and FlashForward (though not nearly as bad as most seem to make it out) just wasn't good enough for me to vote for it over a show I've never seen before.
ReplyDeleteChuck and X-Files
ReplyDeleteLove Chuck so for me had to be him....although Castle is still a great show I just haven't watched as many episodes
ReplyDeleteChuck and X-Files.
ReplyDeleteI can't believe I had to choose between Chuck and Castle. That just sucks. I gave Chuck the very, very slim edge for originality and all the great guest stars.
Castle and X-Files for me
ReplyDeleteChuck's guest stars have rocked - especially this last year!
ReplyDeleteWhy not vote for the show that you prefer rather than voting for the show that you believe will win?
ReplyDeleteI look at bracket competitions like this as contests to predict everyone else's bracket more than who i want to win personally. Just like doing a final Four bracket for the NCAA basketball tournament. I don't pick my favorites, I pick who I think will win each game or round.
ReplyDeleteWith individual polls I usually vote for who I personally like or who I think deserves to win.
I think there's probs a few, around 10-20 people maybe but not a huge amount. You always get a few people not taking it seriously :P
ReplyDeleteDon't forget only 289 people signed up for the prediction competition, and I reckon around 50-60% of those will vote every day of the competition...
Not with me. I've forgotten most of what I put down on my bracket.
ReplyDeleteCastle and The X-Files. If Castle passes, will they go against each other? That would be terrible.
ReplyDeleteYep, the winners of today's polls will meet each other in the next round
ReplyDeleteIt was difficult as all four are good shows. Castle and X-Files were my votes. I steadily watch any shows except Supernatural, but when I'm in the mood, II'd catch one of these.
ReplyDeleteCastle and the X-Files definitely! I am still bitter about Friends not beating out Angel (if tv critics were voting, Friends totally would have kicked butt), but I will have to suck it up and hope these other great shows prevail!!!!
ReplyDeleteAw, that is going to be a very hard choice for me. Maybe next year we can have a finished show winner and a current show winner? lol
ReplyDeleteCastle x Chuck was mean! But I had to go with Castle S2
ReplyDeleteWTF Chuck? I thought the fans were more active than that?
ReplyDeleteWELL I meant both polls in the same post. othewise back and forth for bracket and heart 2-3 times.
ReplyDeleteThat's me. "Didn't I vote for this show? Wait, I voted for that one right? Wait... ???" lol
ReplyDeleteI only watch Chuck out of all of these.. too bad it's losing :(
ReplyDeleteSorry. My brain is not functioning at this time. In that case I think my head and heart agreed about 3 times so far. There were many rounds where my heart didn't care one way or another. :-)
ReplyDeleteHa! In all honesty, the only reason I remember is because I wrote it down. There have been a couple times when I thought I picked one show but it ended up I picked the other.
ReplyDeleteBelieve me, it gets much much tougher. When you have to choose between two shows you have been defending from the start, it gets painful to vote. For me it starts tomorrow. It's Burn Notice vs. Supernatural tomorrow and that's just heartbreaking.
ReplyDeleteHa! My guess is that if TV critics were voting, most of these shows would not even be in the running. That includes Friends. However, I Love Lucy would be getting some mad props.
ReplyDeleteCastle and X-Files
ReplyDeleteI've always wondered why there were not more Chuck fans on SPTV when they and Fringe practically run TVBtN. I guess they haven't heard about this contest yet because they are some of Supernatural's hardest competition in most on-line polls. Then again so is Castle though.
ReplyDeleteCastle and the xfiles. no question!
ReplyDeleteDefinitely Castle and XFiles...
ReplyDeleteGosh next round looks like it will be against these two... both by the fab Rob Bowman... how will I choose?
Wow!Chuck gained like,200 votes in 5 minutes :-/
ReplyDeletethat seems a bit dodgy. but maybe im just saying that because im bias towards castle!
ReplyDeleteYep, my thoughts exactly.Although strange,I don't want to pick a fight with Chuck fans so I'll just assume somebody posted a link to this poll on a fansite :-??
ReplyDeleteyeah. there are plenty enough chuck fans out there that, originally i was shocked it wasnt ahead. it was just the time frame of it's come back, crazyy.
ReplyDeleteYep, saw it posted on a couple of Chuck twitter accounts and fan sites.
ReplyDeleteCastle and X-Files for me.
ReplyDeleteWow CHUCK made a big comeback lets see if it can win now.
ReplyDeleteGo Chuck go!
ReplyDeleteChuck fans have a pretty good network to get the word out. They win a lot of polls too.
ReplyDeleteTalk about a late comeback! It was 12 votes behind about an hour ago, now it's in the lead. It's an impressive performance!
ReplyDeleteCASTLE vs CHUCK has been the best competetion in this tournament so far way to go chuck and castle fans
ReplyDeleteyessss! I'm nervous!! lol I want Castle to win!!! go castleeeee
ReplyDeleteI'm with you on that one ! GO CASTLE!!!
ReplyDeleteOMG Chuck is really winning....never thought that after the slow start...I'am happy...
ReplyDeletefinally Castle lost... only 23 votes!! I'm sad now... >.<
ReplyDeleteWOO HOO for Chuck! I had written this one of my bracket and then I wake up to find it back in the game. Perhaps I should just not go to sleep.
ReplyDeleteYESSS CHUCK WONNNNNNNNN!!!!!!!!!
ReplyDeleteAh damn, Castle is out of the running. Great job by the Chuck fans though.
ReplyDeleteLove it Chuck won. My friend will be so happy.
ReplyDeleteChuck is the best! :D
ReplyDeleteI like How I Met Your Mother .
ReplyDeletedamnnnn, castle was soo close!! >.<
ReplyDelete