Today's User Submitted Daily (USD) Poll was submitted by PaulaIreri who was picked randomly from our Poll Submissions (see below).
Let us know in the comments what you voted for and why?
Want to see your Poll posted on the site? Click the Blue Button below
Rules
- Polls need to be TV/Movie related.
- You must supply a Poll Question, and the possible choices. Please try to keep the number of options to a reasonable amount
- You can only Submit 1 Poll Per Day. Previous polls submitted will still be eligible for posting (ie you don't need to keep submitting the same poll everyday)
Each day we will pick one submitted poll at random to post on the site.
I thought it would be the doctor: he's always right no matter what XD. But of course Sherlock is at least as good as the doctor ^^. I would love to see a discussion between those two O.o.
In terms of knowledge, the Doctor clearly wins this, being more than 1000 years old and knowing more stuff than all other people on this list combined. But House has to be right about everything, so I presume he would argue until his opponent would be too tired to continue the discussion.
The doctor, everyone of them can say what ever they want, and can say that they are the smartest but, when it comes to brain The Doctor wins every time, because of the years of his live and also because of the knowledge he gathered thought his lifes.
But Sheldon has lost debates to Amy before. I don't watch Sherlock but I have no doubt he'd be able to win a discussion. My vote is for Reid who knows lots in various fields of interest.
- Sherlock would not bother to debate most people on most topics since he finds them boring. So he is out... - Sheldon is often wrong but uses cyclical false logic to prove he is right. Plus Sheldon would be screaming like a 60's schoolgirl screaming at the Beatles if he met most of the people in this list. So he is out. - House is House. So he is out. - The Doctor is often wrong repeatedly until he realizes what he was missing in his thought process. Plus using talking points from other galaxies or epochs is not allowed. He is out. - Tyrion is well learned, but could he debate on modern technology or Medicine etc? He is out. - Reid has encyclopedic knowledge of... well, everything, but putting that to use is not always an easy task.
so difficult to choose between Sherlock Tryion Lannister.. But I picked Tryion. He doesn't just truly beat you over the head with words like Sherlock Holmes tends to do...he includes logic and facts.
Good options (well at least pretty much everyone who I was expecting to be there was listed...)
I voted for House, not because the others wouldn't hold their own. Everyone of them is strong headed enough to think they are right about everything. But I believe everyone else would also be too preoccupied with proving themselves right to other person. However I know Greg would be the only one who wouldn't care enough about his debater to be phased by him, he would argue his ass off simply for himself. If he knows he's right all is fine with the world. Everyone else is just an idiot.
NOTE: Name-calling, personal attacks, spamming, excessive self-promotion, condescending pomposity, general assiness, racism, sexism, any-other-ism, homophobia, acrophobia, and destructive (versus constructive) criticism will get you BANNED from the party.
Tyrion Lannister
ReplyDeleteThe Doctor is the kind of person who always does whatever he wants.
ReplyDeleteSherlock Holmes!
ReplyDeleteTyrion Lannister
ReplyDeleteGREGORY HOUSE - from House MD. End of argument
ReplyDeleteReid. Can't lose an argument when you literally know everything. Though house would come close.
ReplyDeleteI thought it would be the doctor: he's always right no matter what XD. But of course Sherlock is at least as good as the doctor ^^. I would love to see a discussion between those two O.o.
ReplyDeleteReid has the most knowledge so most probably Reid would ;)
ReplyDeleteIn terms of knowledge, the Doctor clearly wins this, being more than 1000 years old and knowing more stuff than all other people on this list combined. But House has to be right about everything, so I presume he would argue until his opponent would be too tired to continue the discussion.
ReplyDeleteTyrion or Sherlock... tough choice.
ReplyDeleteTyrion, though Sheldon makes a pretty close second
ReplyDeleteTyrion - knowing a lot of stuff and winning an argument are two very different things, and Tyrion is King on the second.
ReplyDeleteOf the ones mentioned above, Tyrion. I always enjoyed seeing Al swearengen in a good discussion too. Tyrion and Al in a debate would be interesting.
ReplyDeleteMy poll :D lol it would be priceless to see the discussion! I support all characters in here!
ReplyDeleteThe doctor, everyone of them can say what ever they want, and can say that they are the smartest but, when it comes to brain The Doctor wins every time, because of the years of his live and also because of the knowledge he gathered thought his lifes.
ReplyDeleteBut Sheldon has lost debates to Amy before. I don't watch Sherlock but I have no doubt he'd be able to win a discussion. My vote is for Reid who knows lots in various fields of interest.
ReplyDeleteWhy do I see Dan with his bowie knife behind the debater opposite Al? XD
ReplyDeleteThe battle is between The Doctor, House and Sherlock. An argument between them would probably last forever.
ReplyDelete- Sherlock would not bother to debate most people on most topics since he finds them boring.
ReplyDeleteSo he is out...
- Sheldon is often wrong but uses cyclical false logic to prove he is right. Plus Sheldon would be screaming like a 60's schoolgirl screaming at the Beatles if he met most of the people in this list.
So he is out.
- House is House.
So he is out.
- The Doctor is often wrong repeatedly until he realizes what he was missing in his thought process. Plus using talking points from other galaxies or epochs is not allowed.
He is out.
- Tyrion is well learned, but could he debate on modern technology or Medicine etc?
He is out.
- Reid has encyclopedic knowledge of... well, everything, but putting that to use is not always an easy task.
My money would be on Dr. Reid
Hmmm, on second thought I will choose other.
ReplyDeleteCharlie Sheen would win any argument because if you don't agree with him he will get you fired! XD
so difficult to choose between Sherlock Tryion Lannister.. But I picked Tryion. He doesn't just truly beat you over the head with words like Sherlock Holmes tends to do...he includes logic and facts.
ReplyDeleteSheldon Cooper!
ReplyDeleteWow, tough one because they all have their areas. Sherlock with observation and Sheldon with Science, etc. I voted Sherlock.
ReplyDeleteSheldon always wins...at least in his mind.
ReplyDeleteIt actually would be me. Being the size of the Golem in Supernatural usually makes people stop takling and stare when I walk into a room.
ReplyDeleteEither Sherlock Holmes or The Doctor :)
ReplyDeleteSherlock or the Doctor. btw great poll!!
ReplyDeleteSam Winchester could
ReplyDeleteWith puppy dog eyes!
ReplyDeleteI am surprised at how close all of the votes are...Any argument between any one of these characters would be something to see. Great poll idea!
ReplyDeleteSheldon loses debates, he just doesn't admit it.
ReplyDeleteGood options (well at least pretty much everyone who I was expecting to be there was listed...)
ReplyDeleteI voted for House, not because the others wouldn't hold their own. Everyone of them is strong headed enough to think they are right about everything. But I believe everyone else would also be too preoccupied with proving themselves right to other person. However I know Greg would be the only one who wouldn't care enough about his debater to be phased by him, he would argue his ass off simply for himself. If he knows he's right all is fine with the world. Everyone else is just an idiot.
God, i'd love to put Sheldon, Tyrion and the Doctor in a room together! lol
ReplyDeleteTywin Lannister
ReplyDelete