Mastodon Mastodon Mastodon Mastodon Mastodon Fringe 3.18 - Bloodline - Review


    Enable Dark Mode!

  • What's HOT
  • Premiere Calendar
  • Ratings News
  • Movies
  • YouTube Channel
  • Submit Scoop
  • Contact Us
  • Search
  • Privacy Policy
Support SpoilerTV
SpoilerTV.com is now available ad-free to for all premium subscribers. Thank you for considering becoming a SpoilerTV premium member!

SpoilerTV - TV Spoilers

Fringe 3.18 - Bloodline - Review

Mar 28, 2011

Share on Reddit
Fringe 3x18 - In Which Walternate Weaves a Wicked Web and Olivia Officially Becomes a MILF

Not since 'Marionette' have I been as moved by an episode of Fringe as I was during this week’s instalment. It didn’t help that I was already an emotional wreck after learning that FOX had finally heard our threatspleas and confirmed the renewal of the show for a fourth season. I’m guessing the employees at the network are all suffering tooth-decay from all the red-vines they received. This week’s episode was more of the bitter-sweet as we shifted our gaze ‘Over There’. The narrative was focussed and tightly woven, centring intensely on Atlivia’s abduction and its Fringish consequences, leading to unexpected arrivals and unsettling revelations.



THINGS THAT MADE ME HAPPY

Oh baby – The episode began with the drawing of blood. Interestingly enough, it ended with blood as well. We soon learnt that Olivia had an 8 in 10 chance of being a carrier of Viral Propagated Eclampsia (VPE) which, after some googling it seems exists solely ‘Over There’. What I liked about this revelation was the convincing reactions from both Olivia and Marilyn. I thought Amy Madigan did a great job of portraying her maternal concerns and fears regarding Olivia’s choices, but I was particularly pleased by the fact that Olivia was realistically considering the fact that, regardless of the VPE, she might not be prepared emotionally or otherwise for a baby. Of course this option is soon taken away from her, but it was interesting to see the writers playing with the possibility of choice.



“Someone who’ll love you for who you are on the inside” – I call them Scona. So Scarlie and Mona ‘the bug girl’ Foster had ‘tea’ (always a suspect concept in the Fringe verse). It seems like he’s finally found someone to scratch his spiders when they itch. I wish that was a euphemism. I really appreciated this as one of the cuter, lighter moments in the episode and I do hope we hear or see more of Scona in the future.

Henry - Andre Royo reprised his role as Henry, this time playing the hero to a different Olivia. I loved that he had been checking up on her, which really just reinforces the profound impact our Olivia had on him. This character has really come to stand as a symbol of hope and courage - in the short span that we’ve seen him he’s risked his own life (twice) to help a woman he barely knew and then, despite being taken in by the scary government folk who took his cab, and mind-screwed by the idea of alternate universes, he delivers the baby of a woman he’s already met (except not really) on the floor of a Chinese shop while dozens of onlookers gape through the window. This guy deserves a medal or something.



The Birth - When I first started watching Fringe, as weird and far-out as it seemed, the image of Olivia Dunham giving birth was one of the last things I expected to see. We got teased with a sneaky image of Olivia suffering from a nightmarishly accelerated pregnancy in a dream sequence in “The Same Old Story”, which at the time, seemed rather random and now seems like the coolest case of foreshadowing ever.



Once again, Anna Torv knocked it out of the ballpark as she went from last week’s delightfully absurd to the opposite end of the spectrum with this week’s heartbreakingly dramatic performance. This episode also gave Seth Gabel a chance to shine. I’ve always been sort of neutral towards Lincoln and his feelings towards Liv, but this episode sold me on both.



The scene in China Town will go down as one of the most beautifully moving scenes in Fringe history. It was perfectly orchestrated, from the intensity of the situation, to Lincoln’s heartfelt declaration of love and Olivia’s stoic resignation. Interestingly, the score reminded me of Lost’s ‘Deus Ex Machina’ in which a young Claire gives birth to Aaron in the jungle while the inexperienced Kate delivers him. I was extremely hesitant about the idea an alt-pregnancy, but by the end of this scene I was crying harder than the baby.

Baby Dunham – wearing blue and red (and rocking the patent Dunham beanie), conceived in one universe, born in another - baby boy Dunham (born 14/02/2011 according to his blood chart) is no doubt going to be an important figure on the board. His grandfather went to considerable lengths to make sure of his existence (I’m curious to see what his father’s reaction will be when he learns of it, inter-universal child-support must be a bitch.) Either way, with the Observer observing and ominously stating “It is happening,” I’m worried about what the new-born’s future holds.



Other notables - Kick-Astrid was doing just
that in this episode. I enjoyed her involvement in the search, but the highlight was her barely muted reaction to Lincoln’s Jerry Springer-esque bombshell “Agent Dunham is pregnant with Secretary Bishop’s grandchild”. I haven’t said this often enough, but kudos to Jasika Nicole for pulling off this strange and oddly endearing character.

Charlie and Lincoln are finally questioning the greater scheme of things. As we move nearer to the end, characters are becoming self-aware and uncovering more truths. This makes me wonder if the two teams will slowly start to merge towards one common goal – saving both universes.



THINGS THAT MADE ME NOT SO HAPPY:

Brandon(h)ate – I despise this character, and not in a “love to hate ‘em” kind of way. Maybe it’s the baby-teeth, maybe it’s the smug, constipated smirk, maybe it’s the fact that there is not one redeemable quality about him. Whatever it is, I seriously cannot wait for him to die a grisly, violent death, preferably at the hand of a Dunham (either one, I’m not picky).



Act of Hubris – My feelings toward Walternate grow less and less ambivalent as the season progresses. Initially, he was portrayed as the villain, before we saw a more human, more fleshed out version of the character, but lately I’m inclined to cast him back into the baddie role. I cannot see how his abduction of Olivia can be justified in any sense. His means were brutal and inhumane. If he wanted to save his grandchild, he should have sat her down and discussed it with her as opposed to abducting her, drugging her, stretching her bones, accelerating her pregnancy and ultimately (and ironically) putting both her life and the life of her child in danger. Just no.



END NOTES:

The fact is that I was incredibly reluctant to accept this storyline when rumours of it first started circling the fandom. I couldn’t see how a pregnancy would fit in, much less benefit the overall plot, yet now I am not only engaged, but excited about the possibilities that it may hold. This episode had me whipped, got me to sob over a narrative I once despised and if that’s not brilliant storytelling, and then I don’t what is. My only regret at this point is that we have to wait three weeks before getting our fix of LSD ;)



RATING:



9.4 Baby Booties

33 comments:

  1. Dude, even having made the connection to 'The Same Old Story' I had forgotten totally about the freaky dream Olivia has whilst sat with Broyles and then she goes into Labour. Awesome reminder, great review!
    Mine's a bit slow this week, but I'll try and get it done tonight/tomorrow. Quite busy atm...

    ReplyDelete
  2. facebook-632665612March 28, 2011 at 1:33 PM

    Darthlocke:

    I wrote about it on the forum a bit, because it seems like her astral projection from TSOS it is hinting at predetermination of sorts. Even Walter went harping away through the course of the first season, 'use protection! Where a condum!'

    IMO this other hint that the show runners gave about "Trauma" being a cause for memory loss, although I still think they were conditioned as well, led me to the beliefs of Sceintology, especially with whatever possibilities may come with soul-preservation! I think history has been repeating itself and maybe the characters may have visions/memories of counterparts of themselves from another time[line].

    If you guys have time go to wiki and read about Scientology, Hubbard, his [sci-fi] novel, and the story of Xeno...

    ReplyDelete
  3. I agree, i remember the woman giving birth to the accelerated ageing baby/boy/man thing, but i didn't recall the dream sequence. Great review!

    ReplyDelete
  4. Thanks! Yeah, that's the first thing I thought of when we found out Altlivia was pregnant. That scene in 'TSOS' always struck me as weird and out of place, so the fact that it might have been put there way back when as a clue is out of this world awesome on the part of the writers.

    Looking forward to your review, Adam!

    ReplyDelete
  5. Great review. Great episode. I too was wondering if back in TSOS Olivia actually wasn't dreaming about herself but sort of crossing over and seeing a vision of Fauxlivia. Although we can't be ruling out the potential of our Olivia becoming pregnant at one point. After all, they are a couple. We'll see where this goes. And I'm excited that we get to see more stories in season 4.

    ReplyDelete
  6. Ok, that might sound too far-fetched, bit I was thinking something really crazy lately. We know that the observers can bring ppl from the past to meet ppl in the present... what if, considering that the Olivia Dunham over here get also pregnant and have a baby boy, the observers take both children away and bring them back to the past...
    I was imagining that Peter might be the child over there, meaning that he is his own father - yeah, pretty much strange...
    On another note, that blood sample taken from baby boy reminded me that Peter had a health condition despite the obvious machine-related business of compatibility.

    ReplyDelete
  7. My sentiments align with this review completely :)

    ReplyDelete
  8. OH and Brandonate must DIE!!!!
    His character is so effin' skeevy!

    ReplyDelete
  9. after AltO was taken, i kept saying 'it's brandonate. god, i hate him.' something along the lines of going behind walternate's back to inject their synthetic cortexiphan into the fetus & speed up the delivery. as it became clear she did have the VPE, i felt even more sure it was brandonate as he knew about her pregnancy first & came to walternate with it. I considered Walternate's mistress, AltO's obgyn also but nagging feeling it'd be brandonate.. NEVER thought walternate was in on it though.. creepy a-hole.

    i also felt something was waaaay off with AtlO's mother.. could be just fear of losing her remaining daughter to the same VPE but esp after the baby was born i was feeling major creepy bouncing off her

    ReplyDelete
  10. Great review!!

    I love to hate Brandonate, but his ick factor is getting stronger and stronger. Asperger's Astrid is awesome!

    The subtleties of not looking people's eyes usually, not interacting directly usually.. .all well portrayed but not over done aspects of the disease.

    Baby Bishop's red and blue killed me! I forgot to write about it, but when I noticed it a smiled inside.

    ReplyDelete
  11. Really glad we didn't get a long drawn-out pregnancy storyline that lasted 9 months of on-screen time. Having Bolivia in a fat suit until some time during season four would have been annoying.

    ReplyDelete
  12. I want to know what baby Dunham's name is!

    ReplyDelete
  13. If she names him Walternate in honor of his grandpa I will laugh.... hard!

    ReplyDelete
  14. This is the episode that made me truly care about the characters in the red universe. The fringe team being much more relaxed and well oiled machine. The sense of camaraderie between scarlie, Lincoln, and altliva, gives the fringe team over-there a much different feel then over-here. I have been really enjoying the subtle performance of Jasika Nicole, you can see that she care for people she works with.

    I second all those that are calling for the death of Brandonate. The other Brandon

    ReplyDelete
  15. I agree. Characters of the red universe are well written. Scarlie, Lincoln and Fauxlivia are a great team, their camaraderie is great and well portrayed, their bond is totally believable and that makes them 'watchable'. The creators did a good job of making us care for some characters of the red universe....that was not an easy task so condos to them!!

    I think we can say the actor playing Brandon/Brandonate is doing a great job too. As Brandon he is lovable in his 'yeah science' persona but as Brandonate he is loathable in the sense that it seems there's not a thing he wouldn't do....

    As for Walternate I think he really cares for his grandchild and come what may I don't think he plans on hurting him in the slightest way. He seemed really moved by the vision of his grandson sound and healthy and in the same universe as he.....I think he genuinely wanted to save his grandchild (not necessarily fauxlivia) that's why he accelerated the pregnancy. He couldn't have told Fauxlivia because he knows that she doesn't trust him plus that accelerated pregnancy method must be something secret, not known or not approved by the medical world otherwise the VPE problem wouldn't have been much of one to begin with....there was a high probability that Faux wouldn't have listen to him and not wanting to risk losing his grandchild he took matters in his own hands. That doesn't excuse his methods but for me it is giving Walternate a place in complex, grey shaded, not totally bad character area....

    Baby boy Dunham Bishop is such a cutie.....wonder though how that baby thing will turn out? which role will he play? will he stay in the picture for long? How Peter and Olivia will react to this new development? There can't be such thing as alternate universe custody so does that mean Peter will resign himself to not being a part of his son's life or will he contemplate the idea of staying in red universe to be with him?

    ReplyDelete
  16. Very good review, amazing episode :D :D
    I probably missed something, but... who planned Fauxlivia's kidnapping ?? Walternate?

    ReplyDelete
  17. Yes, Walternate was behind the entire thing. He had Brandon orchestrate it while he played the worried grandfather/Secretary.

    ReplyDelete
  18. I can't see how Walternate's actions are grey. Olivia was considering termination, not just because of the VPE, but because her lifestyle wasn't conducive to a baby. For selfish reasons, Walternate violated her and took that choice away. I'm not saying that I'm not happy the baby is safe and healthy now that it is born and in the world, but Walternate had no regard for Olivia's life (just as he had no regard for OUR Olivia's life). That isn't grey area for me.

    ReplyDelete
  19. Grey in the sense that in general he still has a softer, human side to him (there mostly when his own are concerned). It certainly was not his place to decide the future of the pregnancy in lieu of Fauxlivia. He was selfish, yes I'll grant you that but in my eyes I honestly don't think he wanted or wants to harm the baby in any way....as I've said he looked genuinely moved by the sight of his grandson, he truly cares for him.

    ReplyDelete
  20. I love me some Brandon, but I really loved how you describe Brandon(h)ate: "Maybe it’s the baby-teeth, maybe it’s the smug, constipated smirk". Make me laugh out loud. Taken from: SpoilerTV http://www.spoilertv.com/2011/03/fringe-318-bloodline-review.html#ixzz1I3VfQbUe

    ReplyDelete
  21. Loved your review! Favorite line: "I seriously cannot wait for him to die a grisly, violent death, preferably at the hand of a Dunham (either one, I’m not picky)." I'm personally hoping for a tag team Olivia Fauxlivia beat down of Mr. Brandonate. They both have some issues to resolve with him experimenting on both of them. I LOVED that Charlie and Mona had a date. I hope we get to see more of them, but preferably NOT Mona scratching Charlie's spiders. That's one image I would rather keep to the imagination. The thing that bugs me is Olivia's mom. She seemed very suspicious but not in an obvious manner like our dear Brandonate. It was subtle. Subtle enough that I have been questioning it ever since Friday, but then I watch it again and its still there.

    ReplyDelete
  22. And baby boy Peter is ADORABLE!! I just hope we get to see him be a baby for awhile. I'm still coming to terms with the fact the Peter is a father.

    ReplyDelete
  23. OMG thanks, I wasn't sure...
    I think he did this to keep his grandson and Fauxlivia alive because he knew about the virus and Fauxlivia said that she and her baby weren't infected because they accelerated the pregnancy...
    So... let's say that what Walternate did isn't too bad ... ( he made Fauxlivia suffer a little that's not too bad LOL we got our revenge to what she did to Olivia :D )

    ReplyDelete
  24. I completely agree with you, I do think he cares for his grandson, so much so that he was willing to put Altlivia's life in danger to make sure that little Dunham would be born. So, I don't question his love/concern for his grandchild. I just don't think his 'softer', 'human' side is enough to put him in a grey area. History's worst tyrants had families and people they loved and cared about, yet that doesn't make them any less villainous or their actions any less horrendous. In my humble opinion, Walternate remains an antagonist.

    ReplyDelete
  25. Fair enough :)
    To me he is not inherently bad so I put him in grey shade area. I see a man whose son was stolen, an event which not only broke him but also literally provoked the slow destruction of his universe.....I see him as a man who has been hardened by this, who had to make hard decisions in order to try and save his world and billions of people with it. I don't think he enjoys doing what he is doing as opposed to many tyrants whose purpose was to recreate the world as they wanted it to be.....You know, as funny/stupid or insane as it may sounds, Brandonate gives me the impression of being more 'evil' than Walternate lol

    I'm curious to know in which category you put Walter (no sacarsm here, just genuinely curious). Walter too did made bad choices, willing to push ethics and moral to the side but people generally don't put him in antagonist area so I wonder what is it to walternate that makes people put him in 'bastard' category. Is it because he seems more lucid than Walter?

    ReplyDelete
  26. Fair enough :)
    To me he is not inherently bad so I put him in grey shade area. I see a man whose son was stolen, an event which not only broke him but also literally provoked the slow destruction of his universe.....I see him as a man who has been hardened by this, who had to make hard decisions in order to try and save his world and billions of people with it. I don't think he enjoys doing what he is doing as opposed to many tyrants whose purpose was to recreate the world as they wanted it to be.....You know, as funny/stupid or insane as it may sounds, Brandonate gives me the impression of being more 'evil' than Walternate lol

    I'm curious to know in which category you put Walter (no sacarsm here, just genuinely curious). Walter too did made bad choices, willing to push ethics and moral to the side but people generally don't put him in antagonist area so I wonder what is it to walternate that makes people put him in 'bastard' category. Is it because he seems more lucid than Walter?

    ReplyDelete
  27. Once again, I agree with you...Walternate is not inherently 'bad' in the sense that he enjoys bringing pain to others or is sadistic in the way that I suspect Brandonate to be. He is a man shaped by his past...but every villain has a back story. I also agree that he had to make hard decisions to save his world, but so did so did many of history's oppressors who started out as men in power trying to save their country. I don't think Walternate has any real interest in world domination though :) My point is that, regardless his past circumstances, despite the trauma and pain he suffered, he is now murdering human beings as he experiments on them, as Brandonate mentions in 'Immortality' the other subjects who were given Cortexiphan all died. Walternate must know that the other universe (the blue universe) is NOT in fact maliciously plotting war against his side - he has shapeshifters over there to inform him of this. Yet he misled Broyles and Altlivia, manipulating them for his own means - to get Peter into the machine. These acts point to a man who, though not psychopathic or evil, is still what I would consider a 'villain'.

    Walter on the other hand, as morally ambiguous as his choices were (and still are) I do not see as a villain. Walter I would put in the 'grey area'. Before his interllect was compromised, he experimented on children, and violated countless other subjects, which is horrendous and completely morally unacceptable. Yet there were certain lines he did not cross. As far as we know, he did not willingly kill anyone. It is Walter who opposed Bell when he said "Only those who risk going to far know how far they can go", yet it was Walternate who quoted this in the red universe. So even though they are very similar, I do believe there are fundamental differences between the two (just as there are between Olivia and Altlivia) and this allows me to put Walternate in the category of 'antagonist' while our lovable Walter remains in the grey are for me.

    ReplyDelete
  28. Again you have good points.

    Walternate is murderning people in his experiment - as horrendous as it sounds, a case of 'the end justifies the means?', maybe? His universe is at stake afterall

    Walter experimented on children. As far as we know no one died then - sheer luck? He must have known that those experiments could have killed those kids or irreparably changed them, damaged them in a not so positive way. (As we come to know later, many cortexiphan subjects have horribly suffered all their life and maybe if asked would not have not minded being dead instead?) We don't know enough of the past in my opinion to be able to affirmed that the Walter he was then would have stopped his tests if one of the kids did die -- maybe he would have continued in the name of the 'greater good' too. I mean the man almost considered letting Olivia be beaten by her stepfather if that meaned she'll be able to cross over once again! He didn't have the instinctual reaction to oppose it as Elizabeth did (at least that's how I took it when seeing the epi). In the end I think it was the strange closer bond he came to share with Olivia that has compelled him to stand up for her.

    I agree with you that Walternate must know that Blue universe isn't actively in war with them. His actions towards that universe result mainly from the resentment he still holds against those whom he deems responsible for the danger they are in and of course the abduction of his darling son. As I see it he must have come to terms with the notion that only one universe will survive and so is willing to do whatever it takes to save it. Afterall in his mind, Blue universe started it all by disrupting the equilibrium of universes. They intruded his universe first (and I don't think he knows the whole 'saving Peter' story) so...Can't we blame him for thinking that way? I don't....

    In parallel, our fringe team, if possible, wants to preserve both universe. OK. But can we honestly say for sure that this desire isn't generated by a sense of guilt that even though unknowingly they were responsible for the state in which the universes find themselves in. They didn't have experienced the degradation red universe had gone and still goes throught....If it had been the reverse, are we sure things on our side wouldn't have been the same as they are currently in red side? Wouldn't Walter be the same as Walternate?

    All that to say that circumstances on which Walternate bases his reasoning and actions on still put him in complex, grey shade area and not yet on antagonist one....to me he's borderlining it without actually entering it :) lol

    Sorry for the disorganised post btw :)

    ReplyDelete
  29. Okay, firstly, great argument (it's not disorganised at all :) I see what you're saying about residual guilt our side, particularly Walter is feeling wrt the 'war' and degradation of the red universe.

    And yes, Walter's actions were unjustifiable and when watching 'Subject 13', I agree, there was little difference between Walter and Walternate. So, whether Walter would have become Walternate if his brain was not experimented on is a great possibility - then again, he may not have. Since he exists in a different universe, his circumstances and choices are different. Either way, their lives took different paths which resulted in me seeing Walternate as the 'bad guy' and Walter as morally ambiguous.

    My point, is still the same though, regardless of his reasoning, regardless of his motives, he is essentially murdering innocent people. We know Walternate has a utilitarian ideology i.e, he believes that the end justifies the means, so killing a few subjects to save billions is okay with him. In the same vein, he was willing to put Altlivia's life in danger to ensure his grandchild's survival, he was willing to sacrifice alt-Broyles to make sure Altlivia could return and not jeopardise the mission. Ultimately, he is willing to take human life - innocent human life for what he deems 'the greater good.' Now whether this is morally acceptable is another philosophical debate. But I still can't see how that is grey area. There's nothing grey about the fact that he was willing to experiment on Olivia's brain when it would have been just as easy (and more compassionate considering all that he had done to her) to send her home.

    I understand that his motives might stem from a 'grey area', but his actions are destructive and at times, unforgivable.

    ...Wow, I never thought I'd think so hard about this :)

    ReplyDelete
  30. haha I know...Fringe is a challenging show with challenging characters...

    I see your point. I think we have to agree on disagreeing lol. It all depends on perspective. For me Walter and Walternate are not so different....Each could have acted the same way as the other did if put in the same position (Walter could have turn out like walternate, like walternate could have turn out like Walter if their positions were reverse)

    Walter - was willing to experiment on children to prepare our side against a (at the time) hypothetic war that was coming plus risk disrupting the universes equilibrium for the sake of one child (an action which, he must have suspected, could be the source of irreparable and downright highly dangerous consequences for one or both universe and its inhabitants) => putting it like that, it doesn't sounds like so grey shaded actions, it's the character's intention behind those actions that renders them more grey than black

    Walternate - willing to sacrifice some people's life to save his universe; experiment on Olivia, again to find a mean that could help him in defending his universe and willing to ultimately sacrifice an universe in favor of his own after said other universe started it all => in this case too Walternate's intention are good, it's just the means that are questionable that's why he is still mostly grey shaded in my mind. As you said Walternate isn't looking for world's domination, he is merely wanting and acting out to save his universe...That's why while he is murdering people I can't put him in antagonist area....

    I understand them both. Both were acting with somewhat noble intention in mind. Ironically though, it is Walter who is portrayed as the one with a more blurry moral and ethical compass than Walternate in my humble opinion. Walter never had any qualms on experimenting on human beings - children or adults, didn't make a difference to him. He didn't have a problem in pushing any limits away only in the name of scientific progress. However Walternate was portrayed as doing morally controversial things only after he learned that the other universe was responsible for what was happening in his. Before that he was portrayed as someone who uses his intellect in the security field. Never was he shown as the mad scientist a la Walter, experimenting on other things than mechanical objects (coincidentally Peter too seems more in his element with anything mechanic). Both are brilliant but now thinking of it, it always was Walter who was shown as Dr Frankenstein

    ReplyDelete
  31. I just loved this e´pisode and hate even more walternativa and Brandon..

    ReplyDelete
  32. What if Fauxlivia said 'NO' to Walternate? She wasn't yet sold on the baby and could she put her mother through losing her last child from a risky procedure? I think there was a better than even chance she turns Walternate down. He couldn't afford the risk. Plus, by kidnapping her, he had a free hand to do whatever necessary to save the child, even while killing the mother. Plus, I don't think Liv was supposed to come out of that 'facility' alive. The 'kidnappers ' would be blamed and the delivery hushed up. PS: LSD looks a whole lot like an INCEPTION riff or rip off, depending on your perspective.

    ReplyDelete
  33. Well, just remember that Olivia already did this. She entered her boyfriend's mind way back first season using LSD, so it is more likely that INCEPTION was a rip off not the other way around :)

    ReplyDelete

NOTE: Name-calling, personal attacks, spamming, excessive self-promotion, condescending pomposity, general assiness, racism, sexism, any-other-ism, homophobia, acrophobia, and destructive (versus constructive) criticism will get you BANNED from the party.