
I don't get the feeling I'm alone in thinking that 'Selfish', the second episode from House's seventh season was a totally stunning piece of television. Those nay-sayers from last week should be eating their tongue, they wanted to get back to the 'case-of-the-week' episodes, and that's what it did, and boy did it do it. What a heart-breaker and a corker of a case.
I also felt they really cleverly picked the case to suit the developing House & Cuddy relationship, both stories meshing together to form a very solid whole, and a standard format of an episode that should be in the top ten House episodes of this type.
Dealing with the characters, we begin largely with House waiting for Cuddy in the parking garage, as they prepare (how nervous must Cuddy have been, knowing House) to let loose the news that the pair are now "seeing each other with no clothes on." Of course, Cuddy asks House to wait, he agrees, then even appears to invite Wilson into the room to let everyone know. Loved it. :)
That's everyone barring 'Thirteen' who House appears to know more about than expected. But that really is a story for another day, and for those interested, I'm on a screen-writing course, and that would be a 'Plant & Payoff' technique, so expect that to factor in when Olivia Wilde decides to stop making movies and start making some House. Surprisingly for me though, the team was noticeably lacking the female touch I had expected, all three remaining doing a good job to keep the balance of the team. This was undeniably Taub's week in terms of 'team member who deals with House,' his opposing House's relationship with Cuddy linking into the decisions he made in the case.
It worked very well, the writers using Wilson as usual as House's thought processor, realising what Taub was saying was true when Cuddy agreed to 'Foam the patients Lung' (what is that, i was imagining polyfiller :P) and led to some as always stellar work from Hugh Laurie. The nice touch in the episode was that he was genuinely trying to find a solution that worked, old House would have decided to ditch the relationship. But not anymore, he went to Wilson and was brutally honest about his worries. Wilson was stunned, cue some always entertaining Robert Sean Leonard perplexed looks. :P
The second half of the episode saw Foreman, Wilson and Chase all largely disappear, so the writers could get down to the nitty gritty. The patient's condition worsening, the diagnosis arriving too late, her body badly damaged beyond repair. That is barring the option where her brother, already ill could give bone marrow and half a lung to her. The drawback, that he is likely to cut in half his already shortened life. How beautiful was was the son's speech to his sister, the acting brilliant and had a real depth beyond his age (whoever it was playing him :P). I'd be snapping him up for a new show if I was an American Network exec (which I am not)
Other nice bits in the episode was the always entertaining clinic scenes with the old father and son, and also I felt they really balanced the humour and drama in House's character this week, I laughed and saddened, and it was very well paced.
Was this the episode the haters were hoping for? If it wasn't then I don't think they will ever be happy, as this was vintage House, it was classic House and for me, it was the best House episode of the past two seasons (excluding Broken)
And if that's a sign of things to come, then people better get back in the game.
And if your one of the people who said House was done after last week. Well, House will help you out of that one.
"Everybody Lies."
10/10
Did you enjoy 'Selfish'? Comment away folks :)
Adam


I enjoyed the episode immensely and loved the neat round up with the episode beginning with House and Cuddy getting into the elevator with concerns about how their relationship would be perceived (noticed Cuddy pulled her hand out of House's hand in the parking garage lest someone see them holding hands) and ended with Cuddy taking House's hand (albeit off her bottom) and holding his hand as she led him into the elevator and smiling in a very pleased way right before the door closed. House did concern me a little to see him so clearly trying to please Cuddy by "pulling his punches" per Wilson. On one hand, I was very happy to see House so capable of caring about Cuddy's feelings and his obvious effort to make their relationship work. On the other hand, I loved seeing the lovebirds fighting it out about the teenager with MS and taking part of his lung in a sacrifice of life's longevity. I think Cuddy's smile in the elevator showed the pair work better as yin and yang as they were before becoming lovers (a 2nd time). Loving the series this year. Can't wait for Wilson's advice to "set some ground rules" for their romance in the workplace. Love the complications and concerns Huddy has put forth for this seventh year! Go Huddy!!!
ReplyDeleteYes, I enjoyed Selfish even more than Now What. I´m a huddy fan but huddy is not the only thing that i love about this show. The episode was brilliant. Period.
ReplyDeleteloved this episode nearly cried when the brother and sister talked at the end and liked the clinic thing with the old dad and son.
ReplyDeleteSpoilerchicka, that's a very good observation about the hand holding. I didn't think about that. :)
ReplyDeleteI liked the episode for the most part. I wouldn't say it was amazing, but I enjoyed. My review is here: http://housemdspoilers.blogspot.com
I am not a "hater" but even I thought the episode was only okay. I like House/Cuddy, but the ending focusing on their relationship took away from the intense impact of the patient and her family, which disappointed me. It could have ended on a much stronger note.
ReplyDeleteI really liked your review of this. And I went on the message board on IMDB and, so far, there are some positive threads. I think one said it was better than last week.
ReplyDeleteThe conclusion was spot on and I agree all the way
Keep up the good work!
Oh....my....god. The episode was......AMAZING. Almost (note that i said almost;p) better than last weeks. Cant wait to see what House does NEXT week.
ReplyDeleteeven though i have not seen the episode yet i couldn't help myself not to read the review, which i thought was extremely well written and made me all the more excited to watch it! good job! :)
ReplyDeleteSorry to disagree with you AnitaR but if you notice, the ending came full circle to the beginning of the episode where House and Cuddy take an elevator to work together. See my earlier comments in this thread on this. THe patient of the week story was an excellent one and finding the young girl's comment to Taub "Haven't you ever been inspired by anyone?" to be a killer line to the pathetic Taub. The patient story was heavy to bear and excellent. Beginning and Ending with Huddy was ideal as this IS the biggest issue about House and Cuddy working at PPTH. Best part there, no other department heads would supervise House (threatening to even quit before allowing House to report to them). Hope you'll warm up to the conflicted and in-love House and Cuddy. This IS the story for season 7 and could work well as House learns to love and trust or come crashing down if he doesn't have Cuddy there to protect him from his own lost sight about boundaries which he needs often to work in a hospital environment. Thanks for listening.
ReplyDeleteI Agree, AnitaR. I liked it ending with House and Cuddy at the elevator, but it felt a little inconclusive with the family to me.
ReplyDeleteThanks for the comment.
ReplyDeleteGlad you enjoyed the review. :)